Proceedings.

Analysis · Precedent note

R & B Properties: the HST was 'Property', and the principal pays the costs

On November 18, Justice FL Myers ordered R & B Properties' principal to pay the receiver's costs of $23,281.84, finding they would not have been required had the principal complied with the court's order. The March ruling behind them, 2026 ONSC 1826, held that $143,000 of HST from The Beer Store's lease settlement was receivership "Property".

Proceedings. · · 10 min read

On November 18, 2026, Justice FL Myers of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice ordered the principal of R & B Properties (2011) Inc. to pay the costs of a motion that the receiver of the company's property, KSV Restructuring Inc., had won over $143,000 of HST. Those costs, the judge found, "would not have been required" had the principal complied with the court's order; they "should not be borne by the debtor or the secured creditor," having been required "solely to deal with" the principal "and his personal tax issues"; and they were "reasonably incurred to respond to unreasonable arguments advanced by or for" the principal. Weighing the factors under Rule 57.01, the judge fixed them at $23,281.84, all-inclusive, on a partial indemnity basis, per the Endorsement, Nov. 18, 2026, paras. 2, 5–6.

The endorsement's finding is that the principal "ignored the court's order to try to protect his personal liability position vis-à-vis the CRA. While understandable, that does not make his conduct lawful, reasonable, or reasonably supportable." It opens with an apology: "I apologize to the parties and counsel for my tardiness. I did not know that they had filed costs submissions until recently," per the Endorsement, Nov. 18, 2026, paras. 1, 4. The costs submissions are not in the record.

The costs follow Portage Capital Nominee Corp. v. R & B Properties (2011) Inc., 2026 ONSC 1826, decided on March 25. The HST had been paid to the company on a lease termination settlement before the receivership began, and the company's counsel argued that the CRA's statutory deemed trust kept it outside the receivership order. Justice Myers declared it "Property" under the order, whether the company owned it "subject to the deemed trust" or held only "bare legal title as trustee." Priorities, the decision says, will be determined "on notice to all interested parties at the appropriate time." The principal's effort to limit any personal liability to the CRA was "understandable in his self-interest," but "not consistent with the statutory processes," per the 2026 ONSC 1826, paras. 9, 11, 15, 20–21, 23, 25, 30.

761 Queen Street West

Portage's affidavit for the receivership describes the company as "a special purpose vehicle which was incorporated to purchase and manage the Real Property and administer the leases …" The property is 761 Queen Street West in Toronto, approximately 23,865 square feet of mixed-use retail and office space, and the space Anthropologie occupied in it is "the large converted church space on the first and second floor," per the Portage affidavit, sworn Dec. 9, 2025, paras. 18, 24, 27. The receiver's First Report gives "the primary source of the Debtor's financial difficulties" as "the significant vacancy within the building," Anthropologie having left in January 2025 and The Beer Store in December 2025, per the First Report of the Receiver, Feb. 25, 2026, s. 2.0, para. 3.

Portage Capital Nominee Corp. advanced a $15,500,000 loan in 2021. It was not repaid by October 1, 2023, forbearance extended by a series of agreements ended on October 1, 2025, and the debt with accrued interest stood at approximately $16,066,777.98 on December 1, 2025, per the Endorsement of Justice Black, Mar. 4, 2026, paras. 4–9. Justice Sean Dunphy appointed KSV as receiver and manager on January 13, 2026. The endorsement notes that the draft order "has redefined 'Property' to track the charging language of the applicant's security documents …," per the Endorsement of Justice Dunphy, Jan. 13, 2026, para. 4. As signed, the order reaches the real property, the company's personal property "located at or related to or used or acquired in connection with or arising from or out of the Real Property …," and the proceeds of both, per the Order (Appointing Receiver), Jan. 13, 2026, preamble.

A fee paid before the order

Brewers Retail Inc.'s letter of December 15, 2025 confirms the surrender of The Beer Store's premises that day for an "Early Termination Fee: $1,100,000.00 plus HST," per the lease termination letter, Dec. 15, 2025, App. "B" to the First Report of the Receiver. The money reached the company before the receivership order. On January 16, 2026, $1,000,000 reached the receiver. The principal advised that $100,000 had paid two realty tax instalments, and that the HST component had not yet been remitted to the CRA but that the principal intended to remit it. The receiver demanded the HST, "estimated to be approximately $143,000," as "Property" under the order, per the First Report of the Receiver, s. 3.0, paras. 3–5.

The company's counsel, of Glaholt Bowles LLP, answered on February 3 that KSV was receiver "of and limited to the Property": "KSV is not the Receiver of the Debtor." The HST "is trust funds" payable to the CRA; the receiver "has indicated that it will not remit the HST to the CRA," and its demand would "put R&B in breach of trust, and attach to it liability for failing to remit the HST, when the HST is in hand and must be remitted," per the letter of the company's counsel, Feb. 3, 2026, App. "D" to the First Report. The receiver's supplemental report of March 18 says any position it communicated on the HST was "solely to the effect that the Receiver intended to hold such proceeds pending a consensual resolution or determination of the relative priority of the CRA's deemed trust claim and the security interest of the secured creditor …," per the Supplement to the First Report, Mar. 18, 2026, s. 3.0, para. 6.

On February 9 the company's counsel wrote that "The trust, and obligation to remit arose at the time of the payment and is unaffected by the Order," and that "In accordance with your letter, and the original and continuing intent of R&B, the HST will be remitted to CRA," per the letter of the company's counsel, Feb. 9, 2026, App. "E" to the First Report. The letter it answered, sent by the receiver's counsel on February 6, said, as the receiver's supplemental report quotes it: "If your client does not remit the collected HST to the Receiver and/or remit it to CRA, the Receiver will seek a Court order requiring him to pay or repay that amount to the Receiver." The reference to the CRA, the report says, "was included solely to address the possibility" that the principal had already remitted the HST, per the Supplement to the First Report, s. 2.0, paras. 4, 8.

KSV moved for a direction that the company pay over the $143,000 and, in the alternative, an order that the principal personally reimburse, within seven days, any part of the termination proceeds remitted to the CRA "or otherwise dissipated without the Receiver's authorization …," per its Amended Notice of Motion, Mar. 9, 2026, para. 1(c)–(d). On March 4 Justice Black granted the rest of the receiver's motion, including a sale process with CBRE Limited as listing broker and a $300,000 interim distribution to Portage from the termination proceeds, and the HST issue was set down, on consent, for March 24, per the Endorsement of Justice Black, paras. 19–20 and the Sale Process Order, Mar. 4, 2026, paras. 3–4, 10.

Keep reading with a 5-day free trial

About 5 more minutes of this analysis, and 4 more sections. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.

Start 5-day trial

Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.

Already a subscriber? Sign in.

See all plans⁠

Analysis is editorial; every factual claim cites the record. The record itself never editorializes.

Facts and summaries are extracted automatically from the court filings linked on each page; the filings remain the authoritative record. Suggested corrections are reviewed against the source filings.