BDO Canada Limited, receiver of the four Wasaga Beach companies that did business as Picture Perfect Marine Rentals, will ask Justice Steele of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (Commercial List) on December 3 to declare that the Residential Tenancies Act does not apply to the 13 occupied units on the riverside property at 381 and 373 Mosley Street, the former Dyconia Resort Hotel. Its primary ground is s. 5(a) of the Act: the receiver says the units were intended to be provided to the travelling or vacationing public in a hotel, motel, resort or cottage establishment. In the alternative it asks the court to declare the occupancy agreements frustrated, under s. 19 of the Act and at common law, by the physical failures and regulatory intervention that followed its appointment. Either way it wants vacant possession by January 31, 2027, and leave to issue writs of possession to the Sheriff, without a further motion, for any unit not handed over, per the Notice of Motion, Nov. 17, 2026, paras. 1(b)–(g), 13, 17, 23, 30.
The Dyconia was a popular summer destination in the 1960s and 1970s, the receiver's Second Report says, and in the 1990s turned toward youth, summer events and weekend partygoers. Its approximately 2.84 acres front the Nottawasaga River: 14 buildings, 38 accommodation units and legacy features such as an outdoor pool, restaurant space and event facilities, "none of which are in their present condition fit for use," per the Second Report of the Receiver, Nov. 16, 2026, paras. 12–15. A 2021 MLS listing appended to the report offered it as "a great development opportunity for someone with a grand vision" and, meanwhile, "a year round resort hotel" whose 38 units "are rented out to guests year round with full occupancy," per the Second Report, App. "I".
A yacht brokerage and a riverside motel
The land belongs to 1000000152 Ontario Inc., a holding company that acquired it on or about February 14, 2022. The receiver understands that 2661656 Ontario Inc. and 2485238 Ontario Inc. brokered short-term yacht rentals under the Picture Perfect Marine Rentals name, a business former management says stopped in June 2023, and that 1000098231 Ontario Inc. was principally involved in managing the occupied units, per the First Report of the Receiver, Apr. 29, 2025, para. 4.
Bank of Montreal lent under three letter agreements of March 1, 2023: a term loan of up to $5,925,000 to the land company and an operating loan and an overdraft facility of up to $600,000 each to the two yacht-rental companies. Its security includes a first-ranking collateral mortgage, general security agreements, cross-guarantees among the companies and joint and several guarantees, limited to the facility amounts plus interest and costs, from the two individuals who between them direct all four companies, per the BMO affidavit, Sept. 9, 2024, paras. 4, 6–9. In July 2024, the bank's affidavit says, it told the companies it no longer wished to continue the relationship, because of "the declining financial performance of the underlying business" and various defaults, breaches of covenant, overlimits and missed payments. On July 26 the bank and the respondents entered into a standstill agreement. The bank says the companies breached it, and on August 20, 2024 it issued demands and notices of intention to enforce security, per the BMO affidavit, paras. 10–17. The receiver puts the debt at $7,350,841.42 as at July 7, 2024, excluding professional fees, with interest and costs accruing, and says it remains outstanding, per the Second Report, para. 2.
The companies consented, and on October 17, 2024 Justice Penny appointed BDO under s. 243(1) of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act and s. 101 of the Courts of Justice Act, effective at noon on January 10, 2025, per the Appointment Order, Oct. 17, 2024, para. 2. The endorsement calls the consent "part of a forbearance-type arrangement which is giving the debtor time to refinance," and, noting a concern about "the length of time being granted before the order is to become effective, during which a lot can happen," requires the bank's counsel to return that morning to have the order vacated or to show the loan unpaid, per the Endorsement of Justice Penny, Oct. 17, 2024, paras. 2, 4–5. On January 10 the evidence was that the debtors "have not repaid the debt, or any portion thereof, and have provided no evidence of any potential refinancing," per the Endorsement of Justice Penny, Jan. 10, 2025, para. 2.
The first possession order
A rent roll from former management showed 21 of the 38 units occupied, generating approximately $25,000 a month, one more held by people former management considered "squatters," and one boarded up after a fire, per the First Report, para. 18.
The receiver's first possession motion concerned Units 924 and 925. The receiver went first to the Landlord and Tenant Board, which adjourned the April 7, 2025 hearing without deciding the merits, per the First Report, paras. 48–50. On May 5, 2025 Justice Steele approved a sale process, sealed two appraisals, and granted vacant possession of both units with leave to issue a writ. "Although the eviction of residential tenants is subject to the jurisdiction of the Landlord and Tenant Board," the endorsement says, "in this case there is no lawful 'tenant' of either Unit 924 or Unit 925 within the meaning of the Residential Tenancies Act. This is because the Occupant of 924 and the Occupants of 925 have never paid any rent, nor are they party to a tenancy agreement," per the Endorsement of Justice Steele, May 5, 2025, paras. 24–25, 30, 33, 36, 42.
Thirteen units, and the paper behind them
The occupants of the 13 units in the new motion pay monthly, the Second Report says: payments "continue to be made and accepted," and the receiver has collected them throughout. Twenty-two units were occupied when the receivership began. The receiver has made no new occupancy agreements, even with occupants it moved, and has not sought occupants for units that fell vacant, an approach it ties to the sale process, per the Second Report, paras. 24, 29, 32, 38.
The documentation "is not uniform," in the report's words. The occupants of three units entered into the Dyconia's hotel/innkeeper agreements, whose stated occupancy periods ended in January 2019, November 2019 and April 2020. Those of three more signed Ontario's standard-form residential lease, for fixed terms that ended between April 2024 and March 2025. For the other seven the receiver has found no signed written agreement, and none has been produced despite its requests, per the Second Report, paras. 27–28. Its fourth notice to occupants, on April 8, 2026, said that a purchaser "will, in all likelihood, be a real estate developer and will require vacant possession of the Real Property as a condition of a sale," per the Second Report, para. 37 and App. "Y".
The receiver's case for the hotel exemption
Section 5(a), as the report describes it on its counsel's advice, excludes living accommodation "intended to be provided to the travelling or vacationing public" or "occupied for a seasonal or temporary period" in, among other establishments, a hotel, motel, resort or cottage or cabin establishment. The report treats these as alternative grounds and relies on the first, per the Second Report, paras. 39–40. It points to separately numbered units with exterior access and to signage naming the "Dyconia." The land is in the Town's Accommodation Commercial zone, where, the report says, ordinary residential use is not generally permitted as a principal use and a permitted "tourist establishment" accommodates the "travelling or vacationing public," no room occupied by the same guest for more than 31 consecutive days, per the Second Report, paras. 16–17, 19–20.
Keep reading with a 5-day free trial
About 5 more minutes of this analysis, and 2 more sections. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.
Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.
Already a subscriber? Sign in.
See all plans