Proceedings.

Analysis · Case update

Jameson Broadway & Birch: Argo joins the Portage lenders against the stay

Two lenders to James Holdings, holder of 75% of the Broadway and Birch tower's equity, are set to ask Justice Masuhara on November 24 to lift the stay protecting it. CMLS puts the Portage debt at $24,413,223.82. Opposing Argo Ventures' application, the petitioners say the monitor intends to seek a sale approval around December 18.

Proceedings. · · 10 min read

Two lenders to James Holdings Ltd. are now asking for the same order: the lifting of the stay the court extended to it on December 4, 2025, as against Portage Capital Corporation, Argo Ventures Inc. and British Columbia Housing Management Commission, so that they can enforce their security. James Holdings is the holding company the monitor described at the outset as the shareholder of 75% of the equity in the Broadway and Birch tower. CMLS Financial Ltd., on behalf of Computershare Trust Company of Canada, applied on July 27; Argo's own application is dated November 5, and Argo consents to CMLS's, per the Monitor's Notice of Application, Nov. 13, 2026, Part 2, paras. 3, 8–9 and the First Report of the Monitor, Dec. 3, 2025, paras. 5.11, 5.26. Both are set for 10:00 a.m. on November 24, with half a day each agreed, per the Notice of Hearing of Application (CMLS), Oct. 15, 2026, pp. 1–2 and the Notice of Hearing of Application (Argo), Nov. 6, 2026, pp. 1–2.

The Portage application was reported here on September 4, when it was set for September 8 before Justice Brongers. That day, according to CMLS, Justice Brongers adjourned it until it could be heard by Justice Masuhara and gave leave "to update the record to take into account subsequent developments in the matter," per the CMLS Notice of Application, Nov. 18, 2026, para. 9. CMLS's update came in that notice, filed November 18, with new figures for the debt, CMLS's account of where the rent from its Granville Street security goes, and appraisals it asks the court to seal. The monitor separately asks to seal its report on the letters of intent for the tower and to clear the courtroom when it is argued, per the Monitor's Notice of Application, Nov. 13, 2026, Part 1, para. 1(b)–(d).

The Portage debt, and CMLS's account of the rent

As of November 12, CMLS says, the borrowers on the Portage loan owed $24,413,223.82, with interest running at 12% a year plus costs; $2,734,010.49 of it is arrears accrued since November 1, 2025, growing by more than $215,000 a month, and "The Portage Lenders have received no payment since November 1, 2025," per the CMLS Notice of Application, Nov. 18, 2026, paras. 10–12. In July, CMLS's affiant had put the debt at $23,740,728.23 as of July 20, per the Affidavit #1 (CMLS), July 24, 2026, para. 37.

The properties securing the loan "continue to generate substantial rental income," the notice says. From a six-month cash flow projection for July to December 2026, it gives monthly income of $248,322.54 in July, rising to $250,042.78 by October; monthly expenses of approximately $163,400, including the Vancity mortgage payment of $123,413.66; and a surplus, which CMLS calls the Granville Surplus Income, of between $85,000 and $86,500 a month, "or $510,000 in 6 months." Its source is the ninth affidavit of one of James Holdings' three directors, made August 19, per the CMLS Notice of Application, Nov. 18, 2026, paras. 13, 30 and the Petitioners' Application Response, Nov. 16, 2026, Part 4, paras. 12, 15.

"The Granville Surplus Income is not being held for the Portage Lenders," CMLS says. In its reading of James Holdings' consolidated six-month cash flow, "the Granville Properties' monthly rental income of $248,322.54 is being recorded as general income of James Holdings," and after the Vancity mortgage is paid that income funds, "among other things," shareholder distributions of $25,000 to $45,000 a month, professional fees of $35,000 a month, $50,000 a month in income tax payments to the CRA, and "Inter-company Transfers" of $17,500 a month, after $52,282.84 in July 2026. The cash flow, CMLS says, projects a negative balance for James Holdings by December, which indicates "that those funds are being redirected by James Holdings and spent elsewhere," per the CMLS Notice of Application, Nov. 18, 2026, paras. 14–15. In July it had written that "It is not known why the Granville Rent Surplus stopped being paid or where these funds are being used now," per the CMLS Notice of Application, July 27, 2026, Part 2, para. 41.

The August 19 affidavit is not in the record, so what the director said about those payments cannot be set beside CMLS's summary. Neither is the petitioners' application response of August 20, and their November response to Argo does not deal with the Granville rent, per the Petitioners' Application Response, Nov. 16, 2026, Part 4, para. 7. In July, a director's affidavit for the petitioners said that, as a result of the proceedings, James Holdings was not receiving payments from the petitioners on its own loan to them, and so was "unable to service the Portage Credit Facility and make interest payment to Computershare," per the Affidavit #5 (petitioners' director), July 23, 2026, para. 82.

Appraisals in place of assessments

In July and September, CMLS says, it had no appraisals and estimated the equity in its security from B.C. Assessment values and the registered prior-ranking Vancity mortgages. It has since obtained a broker opinion of value from Jones Lang LaSalle and appraisals from CBRE Limited effective October 15, 2026, between them covering the residential properties, several Granville Street addresses and 1520 West 13 Avenue. That information and the rent rolls, CMLS says, "will be discussed at the Stay Application on a confidential basis," per the CMLS Notice of Application, Nov. 18, 2026, paras. 16–18.

CMLS asks the court to seal the affidavit that exhibits them, made November 16 by one of its lawyers, "until the completion of the sale of all of the Portage Secured Properties" or further order. "It is intended that the Portage Secured Properties will be marketed and sold," the notice says, and disclosure "would allow prospective purchasers to anchor their offers to the appraised values," per the CMLS Notice of Application, Nov. 18, 2026, paras. 1(b), 22. The parties have agreed on two hours for that application, at 10:00 a.m. on November 24, per the Notice of Hearing of Application (CMLS), Nov. 18, 2026, p. 1.

Argo's loan, and whether it was in good standing

Argo lent $5,350,000 in 2020, in two advances, to James Holdings and 0993786 B.C. Ltd., with guarantees from four companies and three individuals, according to the affidavit of an Argo director sworn November 5. The loan was extended three times, the last time by a loan modification agreement of June 27, 2025 that set a balance due date of September 30, 2026, per the Argo Affidavit #1, Nov. 5, 2026, paras. 1, 15, 18, 20. The monitor reported at the outset that the 2025 extension was conditional on James Holdings directing the petitioners to pay Argo's entire balance from the net proceeds of a sale of the development, a direction given on July 3, 2025, per the First Report of the Monitor, Dec. 3, 2025, paras. 5.20–5.21.

Argo says it sent demand letters, with notices of intention to enforce security under s. 244 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, on June 16, 2026; one of them, exhibited to its affidavit, describes the loan as bridge financing "in connection with a 32-unit residential rental apartment located on 1925 Woodland Drive, Vancouver, British Columbia." Argo also says that "At the time that the demand letters were issued, it was not understood by Argo that the Stay would prevent it from enforcing its Collective Security as against James Holdings, a Third Party to the Stay." It puts the debt at $10,198,766.88 as of May 19, 2026, plus interest and costs, increasing at approximately $135,084.68 a month, per the Argo Affidavit #1, Nov. 5, 2026, paras. 24–27, Ex. "LL". The loan was not repaid by September 30 and no fourth extension was agreed, its notice says. Argo "is not a creditor of the Birch Companies but has been stayed from taking enforcement steps since December of 2025, with no end date in sight," and should not be kept from its security "while material arrears are accruing but other lenders to James Holdings continue to be paid," per the Argo Notice of Application, Nov. 5, 2026, paras. 16–17, 22.

Keep reading with a 5-day free trial

About 4 more minutes of this analysis, and 2 more sections. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.

Start 5-day trial

Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.

Already a subscriber? Sign in.

See all plans⁠

Analysis is editorial; every factual claim cites the record. The record itself never editorializes.

Facts and summaries are extracted automatically from the court filings linked on each page; the filings remain the authoritative record. Suggested corrections are reviewed against the source filings.