Proceedings.

Analysis · Case update

Imperial Tobacco: the plan administrators say Proactio's work is not done

In the Imperial Tobacco, JTI-Macdonald and Rothmans, Benson & Hedges CCAAs, the plan administrators ask both courts to confirm that Quebec class counsel must keep providing services through Proactio "at the same level and in the same manner" until the Quebec plan's claims are finally resolved. Epiq's $25,676,232 budget will be heard with it on December 3.

Proceedings. · · 10 min read

Epiq has reported that most of the Quebec tobacco claims filed in the three weeks before the August 31 deadline are incomplete, according to the court officers who administer the tobacco settlement plans, and those officers now want the courts to confirm that Quebec class counsel must keep their claims agent at work until the Quebec claims are finally resolved. In a joint notice of motion dated November 18, 2026, FTI Consulting Canada Inc., Ernst & Young Inc. and Deloitte Restructuring Inc., the court-appointed monitors and CCAA plan administrators of Imperial Tobacco, Rothmans, Benson & Hedges and JTI-Macdonald respectively, ask each court for an order confirming that, for the rest of the Quebec Administration Plan's claims process, Quebec class counsel "are obligated to continue to provide services through Proactio, at the same level and in the same manner," to facilitate the completion, submission, revision and distribution of all tobacco-victim and succession claims until those claims are finally resolved. Any reduction or modification of Proactio's services, the order sought would add, "may only occur progressively and commensurate with its actual workload rather than projected volumes," per the Joint Notice of Motion (Confirmation Order), Nov. 18, 2026, paras. 1, 16, n. 1.

Proactio, in the notice's description, belongs to the corporate family of Raymond Chabot Administrateur Provisoire Inc. and specializes in class action administration, claims management, member communications and fund distributions; the plans call it "Raymond Chabot." The motion says it has devoted a team of approximately 150 personnel to Quebec claimants, and that class counsel retained it because they "did not have the infrastructure and capacity to handle the number of claims anticipated," per the Joint Notice of Motion (Confirmation Order), Nov. 18, 2026, n. 2, para. 28. On November 18 Justice Jessica Kimmel of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (Commercial List) and Justice Catherine Piché of the Superior Court of Québec set the motion, which concerns the role of "Raymond Chabot, operating as Proactio, as agent for Quebec Class Counsel (the 'QCAP Agent')," for a joint sitting on December 3 with two others: the Quebec class action plaintiffs' request for rolling interim distributions of 50% of each accepted claimant's maximum entitlement, reported here on October 27, and Epiq Class Action Services Canada, Inc.'s motion to approve its second quarterly budget, per the Endorsement of Justices Kimmel and Piché, Nov. 18, 2026, para. 1.

What class counsel told the court

One of the plan administrators' grounds is the fee approval. On August 25, 2025, Chief Justice Morawetz approved the Quebec Class Counsel Fee at $901,177,915, plus applicable sales and excise taxes, subject to a possible reduction of no more than a $50,000,000 reserve held back from it, the fee less any reduction to be paid out of and deducted from the QCAP settlement amount, per the Quebec Class Counsel Fee Approval Order, Aug. 25, 2025, paras. 3–5. The endorsement released the same day recorded what the request covered: "Included in the requested compensation is $46,598,926 for litigation and other costs. Among other things, this includes fees to be paid to Raymond Chabot, which will support QCAPs preparation and submission of their claims without any additional costs to the claimants," per Imperial Tobacco Company Limited, 2025 ONSC 4497, Aug. 25, 2025, para. 15.

The motion also reaches back to December 2024, when class counsel moved for an order stopping another law firm from soliciting and acting for individual Quebec claimants. Their notice of motion then said that class counsel "shall continue to represent Quebec Class Members throughout the duration of the claims process and, more particularly, have mandated Raymond Chabot to assist Blais Class Members through every step of the claims and distribution process," per the QCAP Notice of Motion (Injunctive Relief), Dec. 8, 2024, para. 16. From those statements, and from the number of claims still disputed or outstanding, the plan administrators draw their conclusion: Proactio's services "will be required to assist QCAP Claimants throughout the entirety of the period. This is necessary to be consistent with representations made to the QCAP Claimants and the Courts," per the Joint Notice of Motion (Confirmation Order), Nov. 18, 2026, paras. 4, 10–11, 24.

A backlog that runs into 2027

The claims window under the Quebec plan opened when the plans were implemented on August 29, 2025 and closed on August 31, 2026. According to the motion, Epiq, the claims administrator, has reported that approximately 80,400 proofs of claim were filed in that period: approximately 26,700 before August 9, 2026, and approximately 53,700 in the three weeks before the deadline, "most of which are incomplete, including approximately 23,800 claims missing estate documentation and approximately 22,900 claims awaiting medical records from Santé Québec." In addition, the motion says, Epiq has reported approximately 26,000 claims filed directly with it in the week before August 31 that, on its analysis, "have a medium or high likelihood of being fraudulent," per the Joint Notice of Motion (Confirmation Order), Nov. 18, 2026, paras. 6, 8, 16–17.

Epiq has not yet been able to review all of the filed claims, "resulting in a large backlog," the motion says. Many of the claims "being returned to the Claimant/Proactio will require the assistance of Proactio," it adds, and Epiq expects that a significant number of claimants whose claims are disputed or pending will need Proactio's help to collect and submit more information. Epiq anticipates, according to the motion, that the adjudication and resolution of all of the Quebec claims "will not be completed until mid-2027 at the earliest," per the Joint Notice of Motion (Confirmation Order), Nov. 18, 2026, paras. 18–20.

What the plan administrators call a shifting description

Under the heading "A Shifting Description of Proactio Role," the plan administrators say that over the last two months Quebec class counsel have made varying statements about Proactio, "advising first, that Proactio would be discontinued; then later that its activities would be scaled back; and then that the role would be wound down as the activities were substantially complete." Court materials filed by the Quebec class action plaintiffs, in the motion's account, now indicate that because the claims deadline has passed and certain services may no longer be required, Proactio would continue "in a different role" following December 24, 2026, once the remaining files have been transferred to Epiq, "without defining it." Those "shifting descriptions," together with the volume of incomplete claims, "create confusion," the plan administrators say, and make certainty about Proactio's help important for claimants, Epiq and the courts, per the Joint Notice of Motion (Confirmation Order), Nov. 18, 2026, paras. 21–23.

The phrase "in a different role" appears in the affidavit sworn October 23 for the Quebec class action plaintiffs' interim distribution motion, which sets out their own account of Proactio's next stage. Proactio has advised, according to the affidavit, that it intends to send Epiq its two categories of incomplete claims "in as complete a form as possible before the end of 2026." After that final transfer, the affidavit says, Proactio will stop sending claim documentation to Epiq but "will nevertheless continue in a different role to assist Quebec Class Counsel in fulfilling their duties to Blais Class Members," including by "ensuring that claimants have access to resources in order to assist them in responding to notices that may be received from the Claims Administrator and providing guidance as to how to obtain the documentation that may be required in order to complete their claims." The recourstabac.ca website, call centre and email address will remain active, it says, and Quebec class counsel "will remain in place until the end of the claims process (a team of at least 5 lawyers)," per the QCAP affidavit, sworn Oct. 23, 2026, paras. 44, 51.

Keep reading with a 5-day free trial

About 4 more minutes of this analysis, and 3 more sections. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.

Start 5-day trial

Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.

Already a subscriber? Sign in.

See all plans⁠

Analysis is editorial; every factual claim cites the record. The record itself never editorializes.

Facts and summaries are extracted automatically from the court filings linked on each page; the filings remain the authoritative record. Suggested corrections are reviewed against the source filings.