Grant Thornton Limited has followed the money on the 25 purchases in its receivership order as far as one law firm's trust account. Lenders that FCT Insurance Company Ltd. insured advanced $18,098,453 on them, by the receiver's reconciliation to the lenders' statements ($69,550 more than the order's schedule totals). After $918,618 of fees and other amounts the lenders deducted, the receiver says, $17,179,835 reached the trust account of JP Mann Law Firm Professional Corporation, which acted for the purchaser on each of the 25, and $16,337,032 was wired on to the trust account of Simran Law Professional Corporation, which acted for each vendor. The last line of the receiver's flow-of-funds table, "Prior mortgages paid out or discharged," shows a dash, per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, s. 2.1, paras. 1–2; s. 2.2, para. 3 and n. 1; s. 4.2, para. 1, Ex. "A". The line above it, beside the $16,336,594 that Simran Law's account received, reads "Analysis not complete on Payees of Simran Law Trust Account," and the receiver's transaction-by-transaction schedule gives each of the 25 the same entry: "Not determinable; pending Simran Law payment directions," per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, App. "H".
That table is the centre of the receiver's First Report, dated November 19 and filed, it says, for the comeback hearing set for November 23. The receiver calls its findings preliminary. They rest on the two trust accounts' bank statements from February 1 to October 19, 2026, some TD cheque copies and wire records, and Mann Law's paper closing files; the receiver has not received Simran Law's closing files, statements of adjustments or payment directions, and it has not audited the information it relied on, per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, s. 1.1, para. 4; s. 1.3, para. 2; s. 3.1, para. 6; s. 4.1, paras. 1–2. The report also records what each firm's lawyer told the receiver in November meetings, each attended with counsel; those accounts reach the record through it, and no responding affidavit or other responding material from either firm or either lawyer is in the record. The October 19 order, Justice Dunphy's reasons for it and the evidence behind FCT's application without notice were reported here on October 22, October 24 and November 3.
What the receiver holds
TD and RBC have remitted $1,052,717 to the receiver's trust account: $759,545 from Simran Law's trust account at TD, $237,421 from Mann Law's trust account at RBC and $55,751 from Mann Law's operating account there. Both lawyers have confirmed to the receiver that the firms keep no accounts or other banking products at any other institution, per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, s. 3.1, paras. 3–5. The Law Society of Ontario, which took custody of the firms' servers and paper records when it attended both offices with the receiver on October 20, has released the paper records after its privilege review and is arranging to review the imaged electronic records, per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, s. 3.2, paras. 1–4; s. 3.3, paras. 2–3.
Twenty-one payments the other way
Over the period the receiver examined, its figures show, Mann Law's trust account took in $142,165,330 and Simran Law's $83,413,915. The net proceeds of the 25 mortgages were about 12% of the first and about 20% of the second, the receiver says. Among Mann Law's receipts were $8,889,194 from Simran Law's trust account, in what the report's table counts as 21 wires, per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, s. 4.2, para. 3 and Ex. "B". "In an ordinary closing, funds flow from purchaser's counsel to vendor's counsel, not the reverse," the receiver writes, though at this stage it "cannot definitively conclude that the $8.9 million relates solely to the First Tranche Specified Transactions," per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, s. 4.3, para. 1(f).
The purchasers' lawyer, Mann Law's sole director and officer, met the receiver with counsel on November 16 and, the report says, advised that the transfers could relate to transactions that failed to close: a return of mortgage proceeds Mann Law had advanced to Simran Law for those transactions. The receiver says it has received no evidence of a failed transaction between the two firms, and that a summary of the 21 payments sent to the lawyer's counsel for an explanation had not been answered when it reported, per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, s. 2.1, para. 1; s. 3.4, paras. 1, 8(d); s. 4.3, para. 1(f).
On the 25 themselves, the same lawyer told the receiver that a realtor or a mortgage broker sourced each deal, and that the lawyer distributed the purchasers' mortgage proceeds as directed by the vendors' lawyer, relying on statements of adjustments prepared by that lawyer's office. The lawyer's counsel also told the receiver that none of the 25 involved a vendor take-back mortgage, and that the lawyer was "speculating" in saying, in an interview with FCT on October 6, that the "majority of these deals" involved vendor take-back arrangements between vendor and purchaser, per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, s. 3.4, para. 8(a)–(b), (g).
Deposits with no evidence of payment
"There is no evidence that purchaser deposits were ever paid," the receiver also reports. Mann Law's statements of adjustments, it says, show purchaser deposits of approximately $8.5 million, or 33% of the aggregate purchase price of $25.5 million across the 25. Its paper files contain no receipt or other evidence that deposits were paid, and no deposit has been traced through either trust account. "Absent the payment of deposits, it is unclear how the purchasers satisfied the insured lenders' loan-to-value requirements or completed the transaction for the purchase price specified," the report says. The purchasers' lawyer told the receiver that the deposits were not paid to Mann Law or in its custody on any of the closings, that "[a]llegedly," in the report's word, they were paid directly from purchaser to vendor, and that the lawyer took no steps to ensure they were in fact paid, per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, s. 3.4, para. 8(e); s. 4.3, para. 1(h).
From Mann Law's trust account the receiver has traced broker or referral fees of $359,749 on 20 of the 25, and has identified four common recipients paid such fees on more than one transaction. Its requests to the purchasers' lawyer for the names of every referral source on transactions where the vendors' lawyer acted for the vendor, and for a reconciliation by matter of the $237,421 in Mann Law's trust account, were outstanding at the report's date, per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, s. 3.4, para. 9(a)–(b); s. 4.3, para. 1(i).
What the vendors' lawyer said
The vendors' lawyer, Simran Law's sole director and officer, met the receiver with counsel on November 10. In general, the lawyer told the receiver, the lawyer had received directions on the 25 to pay the closing funds received from Mann Law "to an alternate payee rather than the vendor's existing lender, on the basis that the vendor intended to discharge its mortgage from another source of funds," and had personally handled Simran Law's trust accounting, per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, s. 2.1, para. 2; s. 3.4, paras. 1, 2(d)–(e). The receiver's preliminary findings put it this way: the lawyer "paid the majority of the closing proceeds to another party as allegedly directed by the vendor" on each of the 25, "and claims she was advised that the existing mortgage was paid out directly by the vendor." The receiver says it "will provide further evidence on these payments in due course as its investigation advances," per the First Report, Nov. 19, 2026, s. 4.3, para. 1(e).
Keep reading with a 5-day free trial
About 4 more minutes of this analysis, and 2 more sections. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.
Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.
Already a subscriber? Sign in.
See all plans