Proceedings.

Analysis · Case update

Shop Your Own Mortgage: a cash-loss claims process and a $35.9 million clawback

PwC's combined reports of November 9 put the revised clawback at $35.9 million against an original $71.3 million, with $10.6 million collected by October 15, and the first seeks approval of a claims process that would disallow the $317.7 million of claims filed by 939 investors and deem each net loser's claim to be its cash loss.

Proceedings. · · 10 min read

PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. has asked the Supreme Court of British Columbia to approve a claims process that would disallow every claim investors have filed in the bankruptcy of My Mortgage Auction Corp. and put in their place a figure the trustee already holds. Those claims, filed by 939 investors with a value of $317.7 million, were generally valued, the trustee says, on the principal invested plus accrued interest. Under its proposed process, each net loser would instead be emailed a notice of its cash loss as recorded in the trustee's investor database, "without any regard for interest owing pursuant to the investment contracts," and that balance would be deemed its claim unless the investor objected within 45 days with evidence supporting a different amount. The trustee would then revise or disallow the claim under the BIA, and an investor still not satisfied could apply to the court. The claims of 13 trade creditors, valued at $4.5 million, would be vetted under the BIA's ordinary procedures, per the First Combined Report, Nov. 9, 2026, paras. 14.4–14.5, 14.11–14.12, 15.3.

The proposal is in the first of two combined reports dated November 9 from PwC as MMAC's receiver and as trustee of the consolidated estates of the company and its principal, both prepared for a hearing set to begin November 30. The first describes itself as an update on the administration "since the last filed reports," the Receiver's Sixth Report of September 6, 2023 and the Trustee's Second Report of October 17, 2023, per the First Combined Report, Nov. 9, 2026, para. 1.16. The second sets out the trustee's position on the investor applications reported here on September 16, per the Second Combined Report, Nov. 9, 2026, para. 1.10.

What a claim would be

The trustee's reasons come down to cost and consistency. The investor claims on file are "difficult to vet as MMAC's records are deficient," the report says, and recalculating them "would have significant cost consequences for the estate." The trustee's cash figures have been reconciled already: in November 2025 the trustee sent investor statements to the 1,150 net losers, whom the report defines as investors who received no repayment or repayments less than their original investment, invited disputes, and has reviewed and reconciled the statements of 903 of them. Its last reason is consistency with the clawback. Valuing claims on principal plus interest "is inconsistent with the cash basis of quantifying Excess Funds for Winners and Losses for Net Losers for Ponzi schemes," and "could give rise to Winners being entitled to file a claim and share in a distribution of funds which was largely derived from the recovery of Excess Funds from Winners," per the First Combined Report, Nov. 9, 2026, paras. 8.2.2, 14.5, 14.7–14.10. The court found in August 2025 that the evidence "overwhelmingly establishes" that the scheme run through MMAC was a Ponzi scheme, per the Reasons for Judgment, 2025 BCSC 1520, Aug. 6, 2025, para. 71.

The clawback, recalculated

The trustee sent clawback calculations to 561 recipients on July 3, 2025. Its original estimate of the excess funds available to claw back was $71.3 million; the revised figure is $35.9 million. Reallocating transactions to investors under their individual contracts, rather than by the names on bank transactions, took off $25.5 million; the contracts, the trustee says, "provide objective evidence to the Trustee as to which investor was the intended party to a transaction." Supported transactions with MMAC's predecessor, later amalgamated with it, took off $5.0 million, and missing transactions, typically ones in the funds-flow analysis not allocated to a specific investor, took off $4.9 million, per the First Combined Report, Nov. 9, 2026, paras. 12.3, 12.6, 12.8–12.9, p. 29 and the Second Combined Report, Nov. 9, 2026, paras. 2.2, 2.4.3.

As at October 15, 2026, the report's table sorts the 561 this way: 186 paid in full or resolved, 62 with resolutions reached and payments under way, 12 still negotiating, 38 with notices of application filed, 106 in judgment or enforcement, and 157 reclassified as net losers. The trustee had collected $10.6 million, with a further $6.1 million due under payment arrangements. The 106 owed $8.4 million and had neither made arrangements nor filed applications; the trustee "has requested and received a total of 145 judgments from the Court," and payment obligations under 39 of them have been satisfied. Enforcement began in June 2026, and a collection agent, CGI Credit Guard Inc., has been engaged for balances below a threshold. The trustee's goal is to complete the clawback by mid-2027, though it says it has limited control over that timeline if the court postpones judgments until tax refunds arrive, per the First Combined Report, Nov. 9, 2026, paras. 12.11–12.12, 12.15–12.16, 12.18.

Three houses and a tax refund

Outside the clawback, the most significant identifiable assets, the report says, were three houses in which MMAC's principal held interests. From a Hawkesbury, Ontario house in which the principal held a half interest, sold in October 2023 for $310,000, the estate recovered $83,000. A Langford, British Columbia house sold for $2.47 million in December 2023, and the estate recovered $109,000 after a Royal Bank of Canada mortgage, a BC speculation tax lien and selling costs. The Las Vegas house, deeded to an investor in August 2023, was sold with the approval of the US Bankruptcy Court, which on January 22, 2024 approved an agreement with that investor and a sale to the tenant, to whom the principal had granted an option to buy at US$5.1 million; the sale closed on February 23, 2024. The trustee acted as vendor, and US$765,000 withheld under the Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act sat in escrow until the IRS approved an exemption on June 18, 2025. After the RBC mortgage of US$4.1 million and US$124,000 of costs, the estate recovered US$828,000, or C$1.1 million, per the First Combined Report, Nov. 9, 2026, paras. 5.1–5.9.

The funds-flow analysis left the trustee concluding that there were no other assets to realize "other than a corporate tax refund." MMAC remitted about $3 million of corporate income tax on its returns for the five years to 2022; the trustee has amended them to remove interest revenue from bridge loans "that were determined not to exist," and estimates a refund of $2.5 million to $3.0 million. The CRA, auditing the refiled returns, "has indicated that approximately $500k of the tax paid may not be recoverable, as certain of the earlier amended tax years may be statute-barred from refiling," and its auditor has advised that the trustee's November 2025 submission was referred to the CRA's Rulings Division. The trustee "is unable to estimate when CRA will complete its review," per the First Combined Report, Nov. 9, 2026, p. 18, paras. 10.1–10.8.

Five questions for the hearing

The Second Combined Report counts 27 notices of application filed under the clawback order, representing "an aggregate amount in dispute of $6.2 million"; its table sets the trustee's revised amounts for the applicants at $6,161,814.15 against the applicants' own figures totalling $3,460,745.52. Two applications, one of them filed jointly by two investor groups, have since been resolved, per the Second Combined Report, Nov. 9, 2026, paras. 3.1–3.2. PwC's requisition of November 10, "Further to the August 12, 2026 direction of Justice Fitzpatrick," asks that the 25 applications on its Schedule "A" be set for November 30, 2026 at 10:00 a.m. for five days, per the Requisition, Nov. 10, 2026. The report frames five common questions, on consolidation, gifts, T5 slips, preferences paid to net losers and postponing judgments, per the Second Combined Report, Nov. 9, 2026, paras. 3.4, 3.6.

Keep reading with a 5-day free trial

About 5 more minutes of this analysis, and 1 more section. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.

Start 5-day trial

Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.

Already a subscriber? Sign in.

See all plans⁠

Analysis is editorial; every factual claim cites the record. The record itself never editorializes.

Facts and summaries are extracted automatically from the court filings linked on each page; the filings remain the authoritative record. Suggested corrections are reviewed against the source filings.