"I remain baffled as to why the Law Society has been unable or unwilling to invoke the rather sweeping trusteeship authority vested in it to protect the public interest," Justice Sean Dunphy wrote in the endorsement that followed the November 12 hearing in the receivership of RSG Law Professional Corporation. The next sentence of the same paragraph sets a caveat beside an observation: "While none of the cases before me have proceeded to the point of judgment and conclusive findings of fact as to what happened, the number and common elements of the various claims that have come before me suggest no innocent explanations that appear plausible," per the Endorsement of Justice Dunphy, Nov. 13, 2026, para. 6. Justice Dunphy is, in the words of an earlier endorsement, "case managing a number of RSG-related cases," per the Endorsement of Justice Dunphy, Nov. 3, 2026, para. 3.
The endorsement that says so is the second one. "I am afraid the Microsoft outage appears to have swallowed whole and without a trace the endorsement I prepared and signed yesterday after hearing this matter," it begins; the text that survives is signed and dated November 13. It makes no order and sets no further date, and its last paragraph turns to who will pay for the receivership, per the Endorsement of Justice Dunphy, Nov. 13, 2026, paras. 1, 7. No order from the November 12 hearing is in the record.
November 12 was the date the October 23 order appointing AlixPartners Restructuring, Inc. receiver of the firm, and of the funds it was required to hold in trust, had set for the matter to return for directions, per the RSG Law Receivership Order, Oct. 23, 2026, paras. 2, 17. That order was reported here on October 24, and the receiver's First Report, filed in connection with the hearing, on November 11, per the First Report of the Receiver, Nov. 10, 2026, s. 1.1, para. 5.
A laptop, and a trust record to rebuild
The endorsement's account of where things stand begins with what was not heard: "The motion originally scheduled to be heard has been deferred as a result of my order of October 23, 2026 appointing a receiver over the RSG law firm and its trust accounts." The receiver, it says, has been able to perform "a preliminary review of the records obtained." The firm, the judge writes, "is no longer in operation at its former address and apparently all of its accounting records have been transferred to the personal laptop" of a lawyer at the firm, a laptop that "contains a considerable amount of privileged materials as well." The receiver has imaged it, the endorsement says, "but a more detailed review must await coordination with the Law Society in order to protect privilege," per the Endorsement of Justice Dunphy, Nov. 13, 2026, para. 2. The laptop's owner is described as a lawyer at the firm in an endorsement Justice Myers made on June 12 on the same court file, per the First Report of the Sales Officer, July 10, 2026, App. "F" (Endorsement of Justice Myers, June 12, 2026, para. 3).
"The Receiver has also begun to receive and analyse banking records but the task of rebuilding a reliable record of transactions in the trust accounts – a necessary first step to understanding the scope of the tracing issues that must be tackled – will take more time," the endorsement goes on, and the publicity around the receiver's appointment "has also had the salutary effect of surfacing other claimants whose various claims will also need to be investigated and incorporated into the on-going investigation." It is not expected, the judge writes, "that sufficient progress will be made to permit firm conclusions to be drawn for several weeks," per the Endorsement of Justice Dunphy, Nov. 13, 2026, paras. 3–5. In its First Report the receiver had said it could not yet estimate when the investigation would be completed or when it would report its findings, and that it would work in stages, with periodic updates, per the First Report of the Receiver, Nov. 10, 2026, s. 3.4, para. 3.
The carve-out motions wait
The same sentence holds out a possibility for the deferred motion and others like it. It is "possible that sufficient clarity will emerge to begin to proceed with the various carve-out motions (of which the present motion was but one) if it can be determined that the files recovered permit a sufficiently clear view of some of these transactions," per the Endorsement of Justice Dunphy, Nov. 13, 2026, para. 5. The endorsement does not say which motion had been scheduled for November 12, or who brought it.
Before the October 23 orders, AlixPartners Advisory, Inc., then the court's sales officer over certain real properties, reported on requests by certain mortgagees to exclude their properties from its mandate. It did not object to some, among them Computershare Trust Company of Canada's request for 5 Studley Street in Mississauga, per the First Supplement to the Second Report of the Sales Officer, Oct. 19, 2026, s. 1.1, para. 1(a); s. 2.0, para. 4. It did not support two that had come by motion. SEI Capital Inc. filed one on October 5 to, among other things, exclude three commercial properties on Pine Valley Drive in Vaughan, where the parcel registers show a first charge of $8,000,000 in SEI's favour. The sales officer said "it appears that SEI is well-secured based on evidence included in its motion record": SEI claims $8,520,145.68 is owing, and an appraisal in that record estimates the properties' value at $18,000,000 as at June 27, 2025. It added that "given the allegations of fraud and the potential for priority disputes as among the holders of registered charges," a sale by a court-appointed officer, with a vesting order, "will assist in satisfying prospective purchasers as to title." SEI's expressed intention, the report says, is to sell the properties through a power of sale, per the First Supplement to the Second Report of the Sales Officer, Oct. 19, 2026, s. 2.2, paras. 1–5.
Keep reading with a 5-day free trial
About 3 more minutes of this analysis, and 1 more section. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.
Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.
Already a subscriber? Sign in.
See all plans