Until the hearing on November 2, National Traffic Safety Management Inc. argued that the court had no jurisdiction to approve the sale of its assets to Ramudden Global (Canada) Inc., because the BIA required the insolvent debtor, not its proposal trustee, to bring any such motion. Two days before the hearing the financing behind the competing offer from A2 Environmental Group Inc., an entity the reasons say the company's director controlled, was withdrawn, and when no other financing was available by the hearing the company changed its position to one of not opposing. Justice Koehnen approved the sale at the end of the hearing and signed the order "with reasons to follow," per Endorsement, Nov. 12, 2026 (2026 ONSC 6396), paras. 2–4, 6.
The reasons, dated November 12 and reported as Re National Traffic Safety Management Inc., 2026 ONSC 6396, decide the jurisdiction question all the same, because the argument was in the company's factum and the company "did not consent to the order but merely indicated a lack of opposition." Their answer: "the court has the jurisdiction to approve the transaction at the request of the Proposal Trustee for three principal reasons," per 2026 ONSC 6396, paras. 5, 10. The approval itself was reported here on November 3, when no reasons were in the record.
Three reasons
The company's case, as the reasons set it out, rested on the wording of ss. 65.13, 50 and 50.4: s. 65.13(3) speaks of "An insolvent person who applies to the court for an authorization …", and ss. 50 and 50.4, it submitted, are limited to monitoring and reporting and do not give a proposal trustee "the independent power to market or sell the debtor's assets outside the ordinary course of business," per 2026 ONSC 6396, paras. 6, 8–9.
The first answer is practice: "this court has, in the past, approved transactions at the request of a proposal trustee without specifically addressing the issue of jurisdiction." The reasons cite Justice Gilmore's order of July 28, 2020 in the notice of intention proceeding of Cranbrook Glen Enterprises o/a Henry's, and Edgemount Manor (Re) and Sheridan Lodge (Re), 2021 ONSC 7803, para. 1, per 2026 ONSC 6396, para. 11 and n. 2. The second is the wording itself: "on their plain language, ss. 65.13(1) and 65.13(3) are worded permissively. They allow an insolvent person to bring a motion. They do not preclude a trustee from doing so." What the subsections prohibit is a sale out of the ordinary course without court approval, and "Court approval is, however, precisely what the Trustee is seeking," per 2026 ONSC 6396, para. 12.
The third rests on the Act's purpose. Courts have held that the BIA is to be interpreted liberally, the reasons say, citing Re Bell, 2013 ONSC 2682, para. 124, and Third Eye Capital Corporation v Ressources Dianor Inc./Dianor Resources Inc., 2019 ONCA 508, para. 43, and its purpose includes "to preserve and maximize the value of a debtor's assets," in words cited to 9354-9186 Québec inc. v. Callidus Capital Corp., 2020 SCC 10, para. 40, and Re Hudson's Bay Company, 2025 ONSC 5998, para. 42. "To deny the Proposal Trustee authority to bring the motion in this case would put form over substance and defeat the purposes of the BIA," per 2026 ONSC 6396, paras. 13–14 and nn. 3–4.
The conflict the court found
The reasons recount that at about the time the company filed its notice of intention, on April 24, 2026, it entered into a letter of intent with the director through A2; the director also took over its operations "with a view to stabilizing the Company and to prepare it for a takeover by A2." The trustee's abbreviated sales process, approved on October 13 without opposition from the director or the company, drew offers from A2 and Ramudden, and the trustee concluded that Ramudden's was preferable, per 2026 ONSC 6396, paras. 15–16.
"The Company's opposition to the Proposed Transaction in those circumstances is the product of a conflict of interest," the reasons find. "The Company would not bring the motion to approve the transaction because it is controlled by [the director] who wishes to acquire the Company through A2 and who therefore objects to the Ramudden transaction that the Trustee proposes," per 2026 ONSC 6396, para. 17. A contrary holding "would undermine the integrity of the court-supervised sale process," allowing the outcome of a trustee's process "to be frustrated by the debtor's conflicted and self-interested controlling mind, who refuses to authorize the approval motion because it would likely result in the rejection of the transaction they favour." A proposal trustee, the reasons add, citing White Oak Commercial Finance, LLC v. Nygård Holdings, 2020 MBQB 58, para. 18, "is an officer of the court whose duty is to represent, impartially, the interests of creditors," per 2026 ONSC 6396, paras. 18–19 and n. 5.
Keep reading with a 5-day free trial
About 4 more minutes of this analysis, and 4 more sections. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.
Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.
Already a subscriber? Sign in.
See all plans