Proceedings.

Analysis · Precedent note

Cleo Energy: no WEPP declaration, and no late claim for CNRL

In 2026 ABKB 742, Justice Marion found jurisdiction to declare the effect of Cleo's reverse vesting order on its former employees' WEPP entitlement, and declined, partly because the receiver asked after closing and after the Minister had decided. CNRL's $88,233.15 cure-cost claim, submitted September 11 against a March 31 bar date, was refused.

Proceedings. · · 9 min read

When the Court of King's Bench of Alberta approved the sale of Cleo Energy Corp.'s shares by reverse vesting order on November 14, 2025, it did so, Justice M.A. Marion later wrote, "with the knowledge that the risk of Minister review and claw back existed …" After the order was granted, as the court understood it, the Minister under the Wage Earner Protection Program Act found Cleo's former employees ineligible for the payments they had received, confirmed that on the reviews all of them sought, and "has taken steps, or intends to take steps," to claw the money back. In reasons dated October 23, 2026, reported as 2755857 Alberta Ltd. (Re), 2026 ABKB 742, Justice Marion held that the court had jurisdiction to make the declarations the receiver sought about that order's effect on the employees' entitlement, and declined to make them, per the Reasons for Decision (2026 ABKB 742), Oct. 23, 2026, paras. 31, 43, 64, 73.

The same reasons refused Canadian Natural Resources Limited's late cure-cost claim of $88,233.15, submitted on September 11, 2026 against a March 31 bar date, and granted the rest of the discharge application of the receiver, Alvarez & Marsal Canada Inc., per the Reasons for Decision, Oct. 23, 2026, paras. 9, 93, 154. The application was reported here on September 10.

A jurisdiction the court declined to use

The receiver, acting by then for the residual company, asked for declarations that the order "does not impact any previously approved claims or WEPP Payments" made to the former employees, and that their entitlement "is to be determined at the time of their termination pursuant to the receivership …" Its case, as the reasons summarize it, was that the decisions interpreting the Act fix entitlement at termination, not by later events, per the Reasons for Decision, Oct. 23, 2026, paras. 6, 48. Its supplemental report of September 15 added that Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC) had not returned, and did not propose to return, the super-priority amount the receiver had remitted on account of those payments, $15,333.41, "a matter that fits squarely in the administration of the receivership," per the Supplemental Report to the Fourth Report of the Receiver, Sept. 15, 2026, para. 14 and the Reasons for Decision, Oct. 23, 2026, paras. 18, 30.

The Minister's memorandum of September 14 argued that the court lacked jurisdiction or should decline it, Parliament having given eligibility to the Minister and, on appeal, to the Canada Industrial Relations Board, and quoted s. 13 of the Act: "Subject to the right of appeal under section 14, the Minister's confirmation, variation or rescission, as the case may be, is final and may not be questioned or reviewed in any court," per the Memorandum of Fact and Law of His Majesty the King (Minister of Employment and Social Development), Sept. 14, 2026, paras. 6, 8, 46.

Justice Marion found jurisdiction, citing, with other grounds, the order's term that the court "shall retain exclusive jurisdiction to, among other things, interpret, implement and enforce the terms and provisions" of it, and the absence of "clear, unequivocal or precise wording to oust the court's jurisdiction." The reasons then decline to use it, first because the receiver's authorities are distinguishable. In Just for Laughs (Arrangement relatif à Former Gestion Inc, 2024 QCCS 3645), Valeo Pharma (Arrangement relatif à Valeo Pharma inc, 2025 QCCS 580) and Synaptive (1001270243 Ontario Inc, 2026 ONSC 3967), the applications were brought "at the time the RVO transaction was approved, and before the Minister decided or reviewed the question …", in proceedings for which, the reasons say, the Act "expressly provides for judicial jurisdiction …" For a receivership, they add, it "does not expressly provide the same express judicial jurisdiction …" Cleo's declarations were sought after approval, after closing and after the Minister's decisions, a context that "materially changes the question …", per the Reasons for Decision, Oct. 23, 2026, paras. 43–47, 52, 58–59.

Nor were the declarations needed to decide the distribution. The super-priority amount, "a relatively modest amount," could be settled among the receiver, ESDC and the former employees, or by the court, before discharge. Declarations had been sought before Justice Feasby in October 2025 but not before Justice Bourque, who granted the revised order, and if the receiver meant the court to decide those issues within the receivership, "the appropriate time to have brought the matter forward was at the time the Revised RVO was approved," per the Reasons for Decision, Oct. 23, 2026, paras. 60–62, 65.

The Act's own review and appeal process was, in the court's view, an adequate alternative. If the receiver's cases are right, Justice Marion wrote, the Minister "may very well have acted without jurisdiction or have committed a legal error …"; the next sentence reads, "I make no decisions about any of those matters." The reasons go on: "Any residual unfairness following that process, or otherwise arising out of WEPPA, is a matter for Parliament." The former employees took no part, and whether any had appealed to the Board was not in the record before the court, per the Reasons for Decision, Oct. 23, 2026, paras. 33, 66, 68–69, 71.

Keep reading with a 5-day free trial

About 5 more minutes of this analysis, and 3 more sections. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.

Start 5-day trial

Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.

Already a subscriber? Sign in.

See all plans⁠

Analysis is editorial; every factual claim cites the record. The record itself never editorializes.

Facts and summaries are extracted automatically from the court filings linked on each page; the filings remain the authoritative record. Suggested corrections are reviewed against the source filings.