On November 17, 2026, a panel of the Court of Appeal for Ontario, Justices Copeland, Pomerance and Myers, granted the Attorney General of Canada leave to appeal Justice J. Dietrich's declarations of July 7 that 1001270243 Ontario Inc. is a "former employer" under the Wage Earner Protection Program Act (WEPPA), per the Court of Appeal endorsement (COA-26-OM-0340), Nov. 17, 2026, p. 1. The company is the residual company of Synaptive Medical Inc.'s 2025 CCAA proceeding. A reverse vesting transaction sent Synaptive's unwanted assets and liabilities into it, the agreements of 48 employees whose employment had been terminated among them, while Synaptive emerged from CCAA protection with approximately 81 retained employees; the residual company went bankrupt on September 3, 2025, per the Reasons of Dietrich J. (2026 ONSC 3967), July 7, 2026, paras. 1, 9, 12, 14. The declarations were sought so that those former employees "may be eligible to receive benefits under the Act," and the Attorney General opposed them on behalf of Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC), per the Reasons of Dietrich J., July 7, 2026, paras. 2, 5.
The panel heard the motion in writing, and its one-page endorsement gives no reasons. It grants leave on two questions, per the Court of Appeal endorsement, Nov. 17, 2026, p. 1:
1. Did the Superior Court exceed its jurisdiction, or, in the alternative, err in not declining to exercise its jurisdiction, by issuing declarations that ResidualCo is a "former employer" under the Wage Earner Protection Program Act, S.C. 2005, c. 47 ("WEPPA")? 2. Did the Superior Court err in its statutory interpretation of the term "former employer" in the WEPPA statutory scheme and thus err in declaring that ResidualCo is a "former employer" as contemplated in ss. 5(1)(b)(i) and 5(1)(b)(iv) of WEPPA and that ResidualCo meets the criteria under s. 3.2 of Wage Earner Protection Program Regulations, S.O.R./2008-222?
"Costs of the motion for leave to appeal are reserved to the panel that hears the appeal," the endorsement concludes, per the Court of Appeal endorsement, Nov. 17, 2026, p. 1.
What the two questions reach
Both questions track the grounds in the Attorney General's notice of motion of July 28. The first takes up its argument that the court "erred in exceeding its jurisdiction by issuing the declaratory relief that it did …"; the second repeats, nearly word for word, the sentence that opens the notice's argument on the meaning of "former employer," per the Notice of Motion for Leave to Appeal, July 28, 2026, pp. 5–6, paras. 13, 19. The order under appeal makes two declarations: that ResidualCo is a former employer as contemplated in s. 5(1)(b)(i) of WEPPA, and that it is one as contemplated in s. 5(1)(b)(iv) and meets the criteria in s. 3.2 of the Regulations, per the Order (Wage Earner Protection Program Relief), July 7, 2026, paras. 1–2.
On jurisdiction, the Attorney General's position below was that it is not the court's role to identify the former employer "as between various entities," only to decide whether the "true" former employer meets the s. 3.2 criteria. Justice Dietrich disagreed: "It is not possible to determine if an entity meets the criteria established by s. 3.2 of the Regulations without determining if that entity is a former employer," per the Reasons of Dietrich J., July 7, 2026, paras. 30–31, 33. The bankruptcy declaration was contested separately: the Attorney General argued that s. 5(5) gives the court a role in deciding whether a former employer in a CCAA proceeding meets the prescribed criteria, and none in a bankruptcy. The reasons found no "clear and unequivocal wording" in the Act ousting the court's jurisdiction, and would not decline it either, because declining risked "inconsistent findings" about ResidualCo's status in the CCAA proceeding and in its bankruptcy, per the Reasons of Dietrich J., July 7, 2026, paras. 57, 59, 62.
On interpretation, the Attorney General's case was that ResidualCo is not the "true" former employer because the employees provided it no services. The reasons answered with the vesting order: it transferred the employment contracts and claims on closing, and "[t]he court order is sufficient, in the circumstances, to form the contract necessary" for a finding that ResidualCo is a former employer "based on the doctrine of common employer." In the next sentence: "Under this doctrine, ResidualCo may not be the only former employer – but it is one former employer," per the Reasons of Dietrich J., July 7, 2026, paras. 34, 46. The ruling was reported here on July 12.
Leave, as each side argued it
The Attorney General's notice argued that "[i]n recent years, there has been a significant increase in the use of RVOs for the purpose of restructuring insolvent entities," which made "the appropriate allocation of limited public funds" a matter of significant interest to the practice and to the public. No litigation step remained in the CCAA proceeding other than the WEPPA issue, it said, and an appeal that would not hinder the proceeding made this "an ideal case to resolve the issues raised on appeal," per the Notice of Motion for Leave to Appeal, July 28, 2026, paras. 22, 25. It asked that costs of the motion follow the outcome of the appeal, per the Notice of Motion for Leave to Appeal, July 28, 2026, p. 1, para. 2.
The 48, through Koskie Minsky LLP, accepted in their responding factum of September 21 that the treatment of employee claims in an RVO "matters to insolvency practice and that the Declaration matters to this proceeding." They argued that the case was nonetheless "a uniquely poor vehicle for appellate consideration": the CCAA judge had declined to decide whether Synaptive itself remained a former employer under s. 3.2 of the Regulations, and the Quebec Court of Appeal had heard Attorney General of Canada c. Valeo Pharma inc. on September 30, 2025 and held it under reserve. They asked that the motion be dismissed with costs, per the Responding Factum of the terminated employees, Sept. 21, 2026, paras. 6, 61–62, 71.
Keep reading with a 5-day free trial
About 4 more minutes of this analysis, and 2 more sections. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.
Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.
Already a subscriber? Sign in.
See all plans