MNP Ltd. is asking the Court of King's Bench of Alberta for authority to terminate the two sale agreements Justice J.S. Little approved on July 20, one for Sprucewood Plaza in Spruce Grove and the other for the Thorncliffe Shopping Centre in Edmonton, and to offer both plazas for sale again, with the same buyers proposed as stalking horses. The applications are returnable before Justice Little by Webex on November 24, Thorncliffe at 2:00 p.m. and Sprucewood at 3:00 p.m., per the Application by the Receiver for a Sales Process Order (Thorncliffe), p. 1, para. 1 and the Sprucewood application, p. 1, para. 1. Both approval orders are under appeal, and the applications say so on the form's line for "any irregularity complained of or objection relied on": "The Receiver seeks to terminate the June OTP while the AVO approving the June OTP is pending appeal," per the Sprucewood application, para. 22.
The approvals, which went to two Gravity Centre companies at sealed prices, were reported here on July 31. The Sprucewood order's stay for a redemption expired on July 30 without the required funds, MNP reports. Also on July 30, in each file, the company and a director of both companies, who had guaranteed their debts to Servus Credit Union Ltd., filed a notice of appeal, per the Receiver's Second Report (Sprucewood), Nov. 17, 2026, paras. 11, 19, 25, 27–28 and the Receiver's Second Report (Thorncliffe), Nov. 17, 2026, paras. 11, 19, 25. On October 2, in Servus Credit Union Ltd v 1109079 Alberta Inc, 2026 ABCA 315, Justice Kevin Feth of the Court of Appeal of Alberta held that the appeals lie as of right under s. 193(c) of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act and dismissed MNP's applications to strike them, per 2026 ABCA 315, paras. 1, 3, 49–50 (Thorncliffe Second Report, App. E).
What the appellants say the plazas were worth
The appeals are from what the Court of Appeal calls SAVOs, the sale approval and vesting orders. As Justice Feth set out the appellants' complaint, the purchase prices "are much below the properties' appraised values and list prices," and MNP refused, they contend, to consider higher offers that came after the offers were accepted. Each notice of appeal alleges that "the accepted Sale Price is so significantly below the appraised Market Value by the Appraisal obtained by the Receiver, and even much more significantly below the Market value obtained by the Guarantors, as to be unreasonable and unfounded and inequitable, leaving significant liability on the Guarantees," per 2026 ABCA 315, paras. 2, 11, 15.
MNP had listed the plazas on or about March 18 at asking prices of $5,250,000 for Sprucewood and $12,125,000 for Thorncliffe, per the Receiver's First Report (Sprucewood), July 13, 2026, para. 29 and the Thorncliffe First Report, para. 29. In the court's account of the background, "No sales and investment solicitation process was approved by the court and no outside date for the completion of the sales process was communicated to prospective buyers or the appellants," per 2026 ABCA 315, para. 8. MNP disputes the appellants' allegations about the adequacy of the marketing and sale process. Its reports point out that in granting the approvals Justice Little determined that the Soundair test had been satisfied and that MNP and its broker, Marcus & Millichap, had made reasonable efforts to market and sell the properties, per the Thorncliffe Second Report, paras. 24, 28 and the Sprucewood Second Report, para. 31.
Two offers after the agreements
According to the director's affidavit, as the reasons summarize it, two higher alternative offers had been made to MNP, both before the approvals. One prospective buyer deposed to an offer to MNP of $4,000,000 for Sprucewood on June 4, 2026, "which remains open," and to an agent's contacts with MNP's agent "on numerous occasions" from April 23, in which MNP's agent acknowledged "lots of interest" in the property. A second deposed to submitting offers to MNP on July 7, 2026 of $5,000,000 for Sprucewood and $12,000,000 for Thorncliffe; that buyer, the reasons add, did not communicate with MNP before the sale, per 2026 ABCA 315, paras. 12–14. The appellants maintain the second buyer's offers were delivered, the reasons say, because MNP's broker replied by text that day that the "2 properties have accepted offers in place, but thanks for your interest," per 2026 ABCA 315, para. 44.
MNP said the second buyer's offers were not credible, the reasons record. Its counsel argued the second buyer's deposits were "entirely out of proportion to the purchase price offered," and MNP said that buyer and the buyer's broker had never contacted MNP or presented the offers to it. Servus supported MNP's position that leave was required and the appeals should be struck, per 2026 ABCA 315, paras. 18–19, 43–44.
What the approvals decided
Section 193(c) gives an appeal as of right "if the property involved in the appeal exceeds in value ten thousand dollars," as the reasons quote it; if it did not apply, the appellants accepted that on these facts they needed leave under s. 193(e). MNP's position, in the reasons' summary, was that the approvals were procedural orders that "simply addressed the manner of the sales, had no impact on the value of the debtors' properties, and did not result in a loss," per 2026 ABCA 315, paras. 16–17.
In Alberta, the reasons say, the $10,000 threshold is generally understood to be supplemented by three considerations: the appeal must be from a substantive, not a procedural, order; must involve, in substance, the value of the debtor's property; and must result in a loss to the appellant. The reasons take that test from Athabasca Workforce Solutions Inc v Greenfire Oil & Gas Ltd, 2021 ABCA 66, and also cite AdvEn Inc (Re), 2026 ABCA 310. "Outside of Ontario, many jurisdictions are moving away from a narrow approach," Justice Feth wrote, but on this record the distinction between narrow and broad "does not alter the outcome," per 2026 ABCA 315, paras. 21, 23, 35.
The line the reasons draw runs between how a property is sold and for how much. A decision that "merely approves a process for the sale of property by a receiver, with any resulting offer/sale still subject to court approval" does not involve property within s. 193(c), the reasons say, quoting earlier authority. "Conversely, an order that is not only about the procedure used to sell an asset, but also whether the asset should have been sold for a specific amount will generally engage section 193(c)." Of these approvals, Justice Feth wrote: "The SAVOs did not determine the choice of the method of sale. The substantive effect of the SAVOs was to approve specific transactions at specific sale prices for each of the properties," and they made a "final determination" of the values at which the properties are monetized, per 2026 ABCA 315, paras. 33, 37.
On loss, the reasons say that at this stage the appellant "need not establish the merits on a balance of probabilities." MNP contended that an appraised value is "not evidence of a loss." The cases it relied on "do not state that an appraisal is never evidence of a loss," Justice Feth wrote, though an appraisal "can be viewed as insufficient evidence" because an estimate of fair market value might not reflect the marketplace, and "A fact-specific inquiry might demand competing offers." The appellants had presented evidence of competing offers. "I find the potential losses are more than speculative. The combination of the appraisals and the competing offers demonstrate facially credible and arguable losses," per 2026 ABCA 315, paras. 30, 39–42.
Keep reading with a 5-day free trial
About 5 more minutes of this analysis, and 3 more sections. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.
Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.
Already a subscriber? Sign in.
See all plans