Proceedings.

Analysis · Case update

QM Group: Phantom Disposal's lien cannot reach the retained project's holdback

Justice Cavanagh lifted the stay for Phantom Disposal's lien action on a disclaimed QM project but held that the reverse vesting order "plainly precludes" that claim from reaching the retained project's $78,035.35 holdback. Intact has produced its settlement; Justice Dunphy approved the lien-claimant list the monitor offered, seeing "no compelling case to go further".

Proceedings. · · 10 min read

On November 2, 2026, Justice Cavanagh of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (Commercial List) released reasons on a motion argued on July 28 in the QM Group's CCAA proceedings, and they turn on one building site. At 131 Farnham Avenue in Toronto, 2386843 Ontario Inc. o/a Phantom Disposal held two sub-subcontracts from QM, one under each of two subcontracts QM held from the general contractor, Eastern Construction Company Limited. On or around July 31, 2025, the QM Group disclaimed all subcontracts on the excavation project; the business that emerged from the reverse vesting transaction kept the demolition one. Phantom sued on the disclaimed project and looked for payment to the security Eastern had posted for the holdback on the retained one. The decision, 2026 ONSC 6188, lets the lien action proceed on the disclaimed project and holds that paragraph 6 of the approval and reverse vesting order "plainly precludes Phantom from asserting a lien claim on the Disclaimed Project against the holdback on the Retained Project," per the Endorsement of Justice Cavanagh, 2026 ONSC 6188, Nov. 2, 2026, paras. 2–3, 6, 12–13, 15, 20, 30.

On November 2, Phantom says, Intact Insurance Company also produced the settlement agreement to which that order made Intact's bond security and rights subject, per the Phantom Disposal letter, Nov. 6, 2026, p. 2, and on November 9 Justice Dunphy ruled on Phantom's request for information about the other lien claimants, per the Endorsement of Justice Dunphy, Nov. 9, 2026, para. 1. The monitor's proposed distribution was reported here on October 27, and its adjournment on October 30.

One improvement, two purchase orders

Eastern was the general contractor for Oaklands Charitable Properties Foundation on the improvement at 131 Farnham Avenue, and it gave QM LP two subcontracts there, one for excavation and one for demolition. QM made a sub-subcontract with Phantom under each, by purchase orders for Project 218031 (excavation) and Project 217708 (demolition). The reasons put the statutory holdback under the Construction Act at $140,739.69 for the excavation contract and $78,035.35 for the demolition subcontract, and say Eastern posted security for both, per the Endorsement, paras. 2–4.

Project 217708 was a Continuing QM Project under the lien regularization order, and a Retained Asset that the post-transaction group, which the reasons call New QM, kept "together with all related Accounts Receivables, including holdbacks." Phantom's lien notice on it, delivered to the monitor on August 29, 2025 for $52,130.46, is subject to the lien claims process the monitor administers. Project 218031 "was estimated not to be profitable on a go-forward basis," and the QM Group, with the monitor's approval, disclaimed all subcontracts relating to it; neither Phantom nor Eastern objected. On November 20, 2025, Phantom commenced its lien action against ResidualCo, Eastern and New QM, without seeking the monitor's consent or the court's leave to sue ResidualCo; it has since discontinued against New QM. The action seeks approximately $280,000 owed on the disclaimed project, and Phantom seeks no recovery from ResidualCo, per the Endorsement, paras. 5, 8, 10, 13–17.

What Phantom argued

The monitor took no issue with lifting the stay for Project 218031: "The sole issue in dispute on the motion is the terms on which the CCAA Stay should be lifted," its factum said, per the Factum of the Monitor (Phantom Disposal Lift-Stay Motion), July 24, 2026, paras. 2–3. Eastern took no position on lifting it, per the Responding Factum of Eastern Construction Company Limited, July 27, 2026, para. 1.

Phantom's case, as the reasons record it, rests on the site. It contended that it supplied services and materials to one improvement, though QM issued its purchase orders "in two streams that mirrored QM's own subcontracts," and that it claims only unpaid invoices under the disclaimed project. Lien rights arise on an improvement basis, it submitted, not by a subcontractor's purchase order; holdback may be released only after every lien that may have attached is satisfied or discharged; and "while its lien subsists, no part of the holdback for the improvement (part of the security posted by Eastern) can be distributed." It relied on paragraph 20 of the reverse vesting order, under which owners and other payors "shall pay all Holdback amounts … in respect of the applicable Continuing Project in accordance with Provincial Lien Legislation, except that any Pre-Filing Lien Claims shall not be considered as preserved, perfected, or otherwise valid liens for the purpose of Provincial Lien Legislation." That paragraph, Phantom said, reaches only pre-filing lien claims on continuing projects, so its lien on Project 218031, "including its lien claim to the holdback amount of the aggregate of $140,739.69 and $78,035.35 in respect of the single improvement," is unaffected, per the Endorsement, paras. 21–24.

Phantom's reply factum put the point in property terms: the order "clears Claims and Encumbrances from assets owned by QM," while Phantom's lien "is instead a statutory claim against the owner's property or the security posted in its place. Neither belonged to QM." Phantom said it "does not challenge the legality or force of the ARVO" and asked only that the order be interpreted according to its text, context and purpose, citing Resler v. Anglin, 2026 SCC 23, per the Reply Factum of the Moving Party, July 26, 2026, paras. 2, 8. New QM answered that the order vested all rights in the continuing projects in New QM and all claims on disclaimed projects in ResidualCo, so that Phantom's claim on the retained holdback "would conflict with the ARVO," per the Endorsement, para. 26.

"The time to seek to do so"

The reasons begin from Canwest Global Communications Corp. (Re), 2009 CanLII 70508 (ON SC), at para. 32: the party seeking to lift a CCAA stay "faces a very heavy onus," and the court looks for sound reasons consistent with the statute's objectives. The court may impose terms, "as the Monitor requests here," citing Nortel Networks Corp., Re, 2017 CarswellOnt 7971, at para. 3, per the Endorsement, paras. 18–19.

Paragraph 20, in the reasons' reading, governs how the holdback regime runs on continuing projects after closing, with pre-filing lien claims on those projects left to the claims process: "This permits payors to release holdback funds notwithstanding the existence of Pre-Filing Lien Claims." Paragraph 6 transfers the Excluded Liabilities to ResidualCo and leaves the Retained Assets "free and clear of and from any and all Claims," and Excluded Liabilities are broadly defined, with "Claims" specifically including liens. "The liability to Phantom for the holdback in respect of the Disclaimed Project is vested in ResidualCo," the reasons hold, and paragraph 6 releases New QM and the Retained Assets, the retained project included, per the Endorsement, paras. 25, 27–30.

"If Phantom wished to preserve a claim against the holdback on the Retained Project, the time to seek to do so was at the hearing of the motion for the ARVO, or by taking an appeal proceeding," the reasons continue, citing Extreme Retail (Canada) Inc. v. Bank of Montreal, 2007 CanLII 36637 (ON SC), at para. 21, and Royal Bank of Canada v. Body Blue Inc., 2008 CanLII 19227 (ON SC), at paras. 19–20. "I conclude that the ARVO precludes Phantom from pursuing a lien claim for recourse against the holdback amount in respect of the Retained Project ($78,035.35)," per the Endorsement, paras. 31–32.

The stay is lifted "solely as it relates to the Disclaimed Project (and not for the Continuing Project), nunc pro tunc for this limited purpose," on four conditions: no claim in the action in respect of a Continuing QM Project; nothing in the order to modify the relief granted by the lien regularization order and the reverse vesting order; no proceeding insofar as Phantom seeks payment of the retained project's $78,035.35 holdback; and, if New QM, Eastern or the monitor says something Phantom seeks violates either order, the court retains jurisdiction to decide it on a motion on at least seven days' notice, per the Endorsement, para. 33. Three of the four closely follow paragraph 6 of the form of order the monitor proposed; the holdback condition does not appear there, per the Factum of the Monitor, para. 20. The judge asked counsel for an approved form of order to be signed; the signed order is not in the record, per the Endorsement, para. 34.

Keep reading with a 5-day free trial

About 4 more minutes of this analysis, and 2 more sections. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.

Start 5-day trial

Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.

Already a subscriber? Sign in.

See all plans⁠

Analysis is editorial; every factual claim cites the record. The record itself never editorializes.

Facts and summaries are extracted automatically from the court filings linked on each page; the filings remain the authoritative record. Suggested corrections are reviewed against the source filings.