Proceedings.

Analysis · Case update

Hayes Timber: Teeswater Concrete cut its offer, then beat the list price

Grant Thornton asks the court, at a hearing set for December 2, to approve selling Hayes Timber's 7 North Diagonal property to Teeswater Concrete (2021) Ltd. The receiver says Teeswater's was the highest of three offers at an October 23 deadline, at a redacted price above the $1,800,000 listing price and the first offer Teeswater made, then cut.

Proceedings. · · 10 min read

In a motion record dated November 12, Grant Thornton Limited, receiver of Hayes Timber Inc. and Hayes Timber Mill Ltd., asks the Ontario Superior Court of Justice to approve the sale of 7 North Diagonal, the South Bruce Peninsula property Hayes Timber Inc. owns, to Teeswater Concrete (2021) Ltd., per the Notice of Motion, Nov. 12, 2026, relief para. 1; grounds para. 2. The price is blacked out of the agreement attached to the receiver's Second Report of November 9. The report says Teeswater's was the highest of three offers submitted by an October 23 deadline, greater than both the $1,800,000 listing price and Teeswater's first offer, presented on September 6. Teeswater had later returned the receiver's form of agreement at a price the receiver says was "substantially reduced" from that first offer, per the Second Report, Nov. 9, 2026, paras. 26, 29–31, 35–36.

Hayes Timber Inc. processed cedar posts, logs and mulch and offered grinding and site-clearing work around Grey and Bruce Counties, a business that, Justice LeMay's endorsement said in October 2025, had been in business for many years and was in its fourth generation of ownership, per the Endorsement of Justice LeMay, released Oct. 31, 2025, para. 3. A Ritchie Bros. auction of the equipment brought $1,100,296 after costs, and the lumber and mulch sold in October for $45,000 and $10,000. No offers came for the rock, which the receiver intends to leave on the property, per the Second Report, Nov. 9, 2026, paras. 15, 17, 25.

Hayes Timber Mill Ltd. was a business bought from a third party in May 2022 with RBC financing, the endorsement says, and it "has had difficulties operating as a going concern," per the Endorsement, para. 4. The receiver says the mill company owned equipment, machinery and vehicles but "does not appear to have conducted any business activities," its assets having been used in Hayes Timber Inc.'s operations, per the Second Report, paras. 2–3.

In July 2024 RBC made formal written demand for $1,097,590.08 owed by Hayes Timber Inc. as of July 17 and $3,474,137.77 owed by the mill company as of July 8, according to the affidavit RBC's representative swore on May 21, 2025; the endorsement puts the debts demanded at "approximately $4.5 million." The companies' two principals had guaranteed the debts, up to $1,400,000 for Hayes Timber Inc. and $3,525,000 for the mill company, per the RBC affidavit, May 21, 2025, paras. 8, 18–20 (Second Report, App. 2) and the Endorsement, para. 6.

A first forbearance agreement, signed November 7, 2024, required, among other things, a $22,521.63 payment, an increase in RBC's collateral charge on 7 North Diagonal from $292,500 to $450,000, and a new charge from the principals on another property. RBC's affidavit says none of those conditions was completed in accordance with the agreement's terms and that it expired on November 28. Once the new $1,500,000 second-ranking charge and notice of the increase were registered, a second forbearance, to March 31, 2025, was signed on January 23 and required consents to receivership, each "effective immediately upon its execution and delivery to [RBC]." After that period expired, RBC's representative swore in May 2025: "The lion's share of the Demanded Indebtedness remains unpaid," per the RBC affidavit, May 21, 2025, paras. 10(d), 22–28 (Second Report, App. 2). By October 2025 RBC put the debt at approximately $866,649.71 for Hayes Timber Inc. and approximately $3,518,212.67 for the mill company, plus costs and interest, per the RBC affidavit, Oct. 27, 2025, para. 8 (Second Report, App. 2).

"Significant concerns" about the first proposed receiver

RBC proposed MNP Ltd. as receiver; its first affidavit said MNP was familiar with the debtors "given its long-term engagement as financial advisor," per the RBC affidavit, May 21, 2025, paras. 33–34 (Second Report, App. 2). The application, commenced on June 2, 2025, was adjourned at the respondents' request in June and rescheduled in September, and reached Justice LeMay on October 2. The respondents sought another adjournment, because their principal counsel was unavailable and because, they said, MNP "was not a neutral party," per the Endorsement, paras. 9–11.

"Having reviewed the file in detail, I had significant concerns about MNP acting as the receiver in this case," Justice LeMay wrote. The respondents' materials indicated that MNP had recently bought BDO's Owen Sound business. That office, the judge wrote, had provided accountancy services to the respondents and, "even more importantly, the most recent invoices for that work have not been paid." The judge observed at the October 2 hearing that it was possible MNP "may be a creditor of the Respondents." The judge also noted that even if the unpaid account raised no conflict, there might still be issues of MNP's suitability; the respondents pointed to Forest and Marine Financial Corporation (Re), 2009 BCSC 1554. RBC's counsel answered that MNP had been providing services "on the express understanding of everyone that they would become the receiver," per the Endorsement, paras. 12–13.

At the adjourned date, October 24, MNP appeared through separate counsel, with materials saying, among other things, that it was not seeking to collect the outstanding account, and explaining why the connection should not be viewed as a conflict. The respondents were given a couple of days to answer, per the Endorsement, paras. 14–16. RBC's affidavit of October 27 says the bank had asked MNP to clear conflicts before proposing it and was advised there were none to report, and it put forward Grant Thornton Limited in case the court "has any difficulty with MNP," per the RBC affidavit, Oct. 27, 2025, paras. 4–6 (Second Report, App. 2).

That, the endorsement says, "removed any issue in respect of MNP." Justice LeMay did not decide the conflict question. When MNP's counsel re-attended on October 29, the judge "confirmed for him that I had not adjudicated the conflicts issue that had been raised and did not intend to adjudicate it," per the Endorsement, para. 17.

On the merits, the respondents accepted a receiver for the mill company but argued that Hayes Timber Inc. "remains a viable business," profitable now and in the past, and should run "with only a monitor to supervise it." The judge had three concerns. The operating line, down to $423,000 by August 26, 2025, was back up to $475,000. A government contract of about $250,000, which a principal's September 30 affidavit said Hayes Timber expected to win, went without an update in the materials for the later October hearings, which the judge called a smaller issue but "indicative of the fact that the Respondents' promises of repayment are not matching the reality." And an agreement entered into shortly before October 2 to sell what the endorsement calls the quarry property for $2 million, with five years' continued use and an April 1, 2026 closing, had called for a deposit by October 1; the materials for October 29 made clear the deposit "is not required for some time," per the Endorsement, paras. 20, 29–32.

The judge found it "just and convenient" to appoint a receiver over all of the assets of both companies, noting that in the second forbearance the respondents had consented to one, and wrote that it appeared funds from the mill company's assets "should be realized first, while consideration should be given by the receiver to operating the Hayes Timber business as a going concern for as long as possible," per the Endorsement, paras. 28, 33, 35. The receivership order of October 29 appointed Grant Thornton Limited and left open whether RBC should pay the respondents' costs of the part of the application spent on MNP, per the Receivership Order, Oct. 29, 2025, paras. 2, 32 and the Endorsement, paras. 36–38.

Keep reading with a 5-day free trial

About 5 more minutes of this analysis, and 3 more sections. Every fact in it cites the filing it was read from.

Start 5-day trial

Card required. Nothing charged for 5 days. Cancel anytime.

Already a subscriber? Sign in.

See all plans⁠

Analysis is editorial; every factual claim cites the record. The record itself never editorializes.

Facts and summaries are extracted automatically from the court filings linked on each page; the filings remain the authoritative record. Suggested corrections are reviewed against the source filings.