Windsor Machine & Stamping Limited, et al

Judge	Court	On this docket	Cases on record
Justice Morawetz	Ontario Superior Court of Justice	19 orders, Oct 2008 – Oct 2011	130 cases on record
Justice Mesbur	Ontario Superior Court of Justice	2 orders, Sep 2008 – Dec 2008	31 cases on record

Counsel of record

Party	Counsel	First seen	Source
ApplicantWindsor Machine & Stamping Limited, et al	Ducharme Fox LLP · Miller Thomson LLP	6 Aug 2008	Order · 29 Oct 2008
CreditorProceeding commenced at Toronto	Ogilvy Renault LLP (now Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLP)	11 Mar 2009	Order · 11 Mar 2009
CreditorProposed Chief Restructuring Officer	Bennett Jones LLP	6 Aug 2008	Application · 6 Aug 2008
CreditorRSM Richter Inc	Ogilvy Renault LLP (now Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLP)	11 Mar 2009	Order · 11 Mar 2009
CreditorU.A.W, Local 25k	Koskie Minsky LLP	26 Feb 2009	Endorsement · 26 Feb 2009

RecoveriesAs stated in the filings

Closed · the record states no distribution outcome.

Fees and ratesAs stated in the filings

9 engagements · 5 firms — latest: Ogilvy, 1 Nov – 31 Dec 2008Sixth Report of the Monitor · 23 Feb 2009

Firm

Period

Hours

Fees

Rates

Source

Bennett Jones LLPCounsel

—Sought

—

$75,204.15incl. tax

not stated

Third Report of the Chief Restructuring Advisor · 2 Dec 2008

Doyle Salewski Inc.capacity not statedperiod 2 of 2

4 Aug – 30 Nov 2008Sought

234.3

$69,335.00ex. tax

not stated

Third Report of the Chief Restructuring Advisor · 2 Dec 2008

0 people — Doyle Salewski Inc., 4 Aug – 30 Nov 2008

Name	Title	Hours	Rate	Fees
Manager	Manager	117.3	$275	$32,257.50
Snr Associates	Snr Associates	1.9	$180	$342.00
Technicians	Technicians	1.2	$90	$108.00
Total	—	234.3	—	$69,335.00

Doyle Salewski Inc.capacity not statedperiod 1 of 2

24 Jun – 3 Aug 2008

—

$21,786.50

$3901 person

First Report of the Chief Restructuring Advisor · 27 Aug 2008

1 person — Doyle Salewski Inc., 24 Jun – 3 Aug 2008

Name	Title	Hours	Rate	Fees
Brian Doyle	—	1	$390	$390.00

OgilvyMonitor

1 Nov – 31 Dec 2008

—

$690.45stated average

Sixth Report of the Monitor · 23 Feb 2009

Ogilvy Renault LLPCounsel to the monitor

—

$170 – $7506 people

Fourth Report of the Monitor · 2 Dec 2008

6 people — Ogilvy Renault LLP, —

Name	Year of call	Hours	Rate	Fees
Tony Reyes	1988	182.75	$750	$137,062.50
M. J. Marquardt	2007	0.5	$585	$292.50
C. N. Hunter	2000	3.25	$515	$1,673.75
J. Stam	2002	44.75	$500	$22,375.00
J. Paquette	1996	7.25	$490	$3,552.50
Penny Adams	Law Clerk	38.5	$170	$6,545.00

RSM Richter Inc.Monitorperiod 4 of 4 · firm not named in the heading

1 Nov – 31 Dec 2008

—

not stated

Sixth Report of the Monitor · 23 Feb 2009

RSM Richter Inc.Monitorperiod 3 of 4 · firm not named in the heading

to 31 Oct 2008

1,383

$168,475.00ex. tax

$250 – $5953 people

Fourth Report of the Monitor · 2 Dec 2008

3 people — RSM Richter Inc., to 31 Oct 2008

Name	Title	Hours	Rate	Fees
Robert Kofman	—	76.25	$595	$45,368.75
Lana Bezner	—	185	$425	$78,625.00
John Grant	—	164.5	$250	$41,125.00
Robert Kofman	Vice-President	—	$582stated averageWeighted Average Billing Rate	—
Lana Bezner	Manager	—	$408stated averageWeighted Average Billing Rate	—
John Grant	Associate	—	$233stated averageWeighted Average Billing Rate	—
Administration & Other	—	—	—	$3,356.25
Other staff and administrative	—	—	$50 – $275Weighted Average Billing Rate	—

RSM Richter Inc.Monitorperiod 2 of 4 · firm not named in the heading

to 30 Sep 2008

—

$149,027.50ex. tax

$225 – $5753 people

Fourth Report of the Monitor · 2 Dec 2008

3 people — RSM Richter Inc., to 30 Sep 2008

Name	Title	Hours	Rate	Fees
Robert Kofman	—	56.5	$575	$32,487.50
Lana Bezner	—	177.25	$400	$70,900.00
John Grant	—	192	$225	$43,200.00
Administration & Other	—	—	—	$2,440.00

RSM Richter Inc.Monitorperiod 1 of 4 · firm not named in the heading

to 31 Aug 2008

—

$164,972.50ex. tax

$225 – $5753 people

Fourth Report of the Monitor · 2 Dec 2008

3 people — RSM Richter Inc., to 31 Aug 2008

Name	Title	Hours	Rate	Fees
Robert Kofman	—	86.25	$575	$49,593.75
Lana Bezner	—	202	$400	$80,800.00
John Grant	—	129	$225	$29,025.00

Documents

66 filings

Date	Document	File
24 Oct 2011	Discharge Order dated October 24, 2011 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

24 Oct 2011	Endorsement dated October 24, 2011	PDF

24 Oct 2011	Motion Record (including Ninth Report of the Monitor) dated October 24, 2011	PDF

24 Oct 2011	Settlement Agreement Order dated October 24, 2011 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

9 Apr 2009	Endorsement dated April 9, 2009	PDF

31 Mar 2009	Endorsement dated March 31, 2009	PDF

31 Mar 2009	Motion Record (including Eighth Report of the Monitor) returnable March 31, 2009	PDF

31 Mar 2009	Order dated March 31, 2009 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

11 Mar 2009	Approval and Distribution Order dated March 11, 2009 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

11 Mar 2009	Endorsement dated March 11, 2009	PDF

11 Mar 2009	Motion Record (including Seventh Report of the Monitor) returnable March 11, 2009	PDF

11 Mar 2009	Order dated March 11, 2009 Counsel Ogilvy Renault LLP Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

11 Mar 2009	Vesting Order (re: 383301 Ontario Limited) dated March 11, 2009 Counsel Ogilvy Renault LLP Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

11 Mar 2009	Vesting Order (re: Lipel Investments Limited) dated March 11, 2009 Counsel Ogilvy Renault LLP Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

11 Mar 2009	Vesting Order (re: Windsor Machine and Stamping (2009) Limited) dated March 11, 2009 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

26 Feb 2009	Endorsement dated February 26, 2009	PDF

26 Feb 2009	Endorsement for March 6 motion dated February 26, 2009 Counsel Koskie Minsky LLP	PDF

26 Feb 2009	Motion Record returnable February 26, 2009	PDF

26 Feb 2009	Order dated February 26, 2009 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

24 Feb 2009	Motion Record returnable February 24, 2009	PDF

24 Feb 2009	Responding Motion Record returnable February 24, 2009	PDF

23 Feb 2009	Sixth Report of the Monitor dated February 23, 2009 Fee schedule Engagements: Form: prose · Rows: · Money: Approximate: false · Period: End: 2008-12-31 · Kind: invoice · Quote: for the period from November 1, 2008 to December 31, 2008 · Start: 2008-11-01 · Approval: State: unstated · Averages: · Currency: · Invoices: · Firm text: RSM Richter Inc. · Firm quote: This report is filed by RSM Richter Inc. ("Richter") in its capacity as monitor ("Monitor") of Windsor Machine & Stamping Limited · Context quote: in its capacity as monitor ("Monitor") of Windsor Machine & Stamping Limited; Form: prose · Rows: · Money: Approximate: false · Period: End: 2008-12-31 · Kind: invoice · Quote: for the period from November 1, 2008 to December 31, 2008 · Start: 2008-11-01 · Approval: State: unstated · Averages: — · Currency: · Invoices: · Firm text: Ogilvy · Firm quote: Detailed invoices in respect of the fees and disbursements of the Monitor and Ogilvy for the period from November 1, 2008 to December 31, 2008, are provided in exhibits to the affidavits of representatives of the Monitor and Ogilvy · Context quote: Detailed invoices in respect of the fees and disbursements of the Monitor and Ogilvy for the period from November 1, 2008 to December 31, 2008	PDF

20 Feb 2009	Endorsement dated February 20, 2009	PDF

30 Jan 2009	Discharge Order dated January 30, 2009	PDF

30 Jan 2009	Endorsement dated January 30, 2009	PDF

30 Jan 2009	Motion Record returnable January 30, 2009	PDF

30 Jan 2009	Stay Extension Order dated January 30, 2009 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

26 Jan 2009	Fifth Report of the Monitor dated January 26, 2009	PDF

23 Jan 2009	Motion Record dated January 23, 2009	PDF

5 Dec 2008	Motion Record returnable December 5, 2008	PDF

5 Dec 2008	Order dated December 5, 2008 Presiding officer Justice Mesbur	PDF

2 Dec 2008	Fourth Report of the Monitor dated December 2, 2008 Fee schedule Engagements: Form: time_summary · Rows: Robert Kofman; Lana Bezner; John Grant · Money: Tax: $9.15K · Label: GST · Quote: GST \| 9,151.17 · Fees: $165K · Quote: Our Fee (per attached time summary) \| $ 164,972.50 · Total: $192K · Quote: Total Due \| 192,174.52 · includes tax · includes disbursements · Approximate: false · Disbursements: $18.1K · Quote: Out of Pocket Expenses \| 18,050.85 · Period: End: 2008-08-31 · Kind: invoice · Quote: For the Period Ending August 31, 2008 · Approval: State: unstated · Averages: · Currency: · Invoices: · Firm text: RSM Richter Inc. · Firm quote: RSM Richter Inc. · Context quote: This report is filed by RSM Richter Inc. ("Richter") in its capacity as monitor ("Monitor") of Windsor Machine & Stamping Limited; Form: time_summary · Rows: Robert Kofman; Lana Bezner; John Grant; Fees: 2440 · Quote: Administration & Other \| \| \| 2,440.00 · Row kind: bucket · Rate kind: standard · Name as stated: Administration & Other · Money: Tax: $7.83K · Label: GST · Quote: GST \| 7,825.29 · Fees: $149K · Quote: Our Fee (per attached time summary) \| $ 149,027.50 · Total: $164K · Quote: Total Due \| 164,331.01 · includes tax · includes disbursements · Approximate: false · Disbursements: $7.48K · Quote: Out of Pocket Expenses \| 7,478.22 · Period: End: 2008-09-30 · Kind: invoice · Quote: For the Period Ending September 30, 2008 · Approval: State: unstated · Averages: · Currency: · Invoices: · Firm text: RSM Richter Inc. · Firm quote: RSM Richter Inc. · Context quote: This report is filed by RSM Richter Inc. ("Richter") in its capacity as monitor ("Monitor") of Windsor Machine & Stamping Limited · Discount note: Text: reduced John Grant's standard hourly charge-out rate from $300 to $225 · Quote: Please note that we have reduced John Grant's standard hourly charge-out rate from $300 to $225.; Form: time_summary · Rows: Robert Kofman; Lana Bezner; John Grant; Fees: 3356.25 · Quote: Administration & Other \| \| \| \| 3,356.25 · Row kind: bucket · Rate kind: standard · Name as stated: Administration & Other · Money: Tax: $9.43K · Label: GST · Quote: GST \| 9,432.97 · Fees: $168K · Quote: Our Fee (per attached time summary) \| $ 168,475.00 · Total: $198K · Quote: Total Due \| 198,092.36 · includes tax · includes disbursements · Approximate: false · Disbursements: $20.2K · Quote: Out of Pocket Expenses \| 20,184.39 · Period: End: 2008-10-31 · Kind: invoice · Quote: For the Period Ending October 31, 2008 · Approval: State: unstated · Averages: · Currency: · Invoices: · Firm text: RSM Richter Inc. · Firm quote: RSM Richter Inc. · Context quote: This report is filed by RSM Richter Inc. ("Richter") in its capacity as monitor ("Monitor") of Windsor Machine & Stamping Limited · Discount note: Text: reduced John Grant's standard hourly charge-out rate by $75 per hour (from $325 to $250) · Quote: we have reduced John Grant's standard hourly charge-out rate by $75 per hour (from $325 to $250).; Form: level_summary · Rows: Rate: 582 · Quote: Robert Kofman \| Vice-President \| 575 \| 595 \| 582 · Title: Vice-President · Row kind: level · Rate kind: average · Rate label: Weighted Average Billing Rate · Name as stated: Robert Kofman; Rate: 408 · Quote: Lana Bezner \| Manager \| 400 \| 425 \| 408 · Title: Manager · Row kind: level · Rate kind: average · Rate label: Weighted Average Billing Rate · Name as stated: Lana Bezner; Rate: 233 · Quote: John Grant \| Associate \| 225 \| 250 \| 233 · Title: Associate · Row kind: level · Rate kind: average · Rate label: Weighted Average Billing Rate · Name as stated: John Grant; Quote: Other staff and administrative \| \| 50 - 275 \| 50 - 275 \| 50 - 275 · Rate max: 275 · Rate min: 50 · Row kind: bucket · Rate kind: range · Rate label: Weighted Average Billing Rate · Name as stated: Other staff and administrative · Money: Fees: $482K · Quote: Total fees ($) \| 482,475 · Approximate: false · Period: End: 2008-10-31 · Kind: cumulative · Quote: Weighted Average Billing Rate · Approval: State: unstated · Averages: — · Currency: · Invoices: · Firm text: RSM Richter Inc. · Firm quote: RSM Richter Inc. · Hours total: Quote: Total hours \| 1,383 · Value: 1383 · Context quote: This report is filed by RSM Richter Inc. ("Richter") in its capacity as monitor ("Monitor") of Windsor Machine & Stamping Limited; Form: rate_chart · Rows: J. Stam; T. Reyes; J. Paquette; P. Adams; C. N. Hunter; M. J. Marquardt · Money: Approximate: false · Period: Kind: unstated · Approval: State: unstated · Averages: — · Currency: · Invoices: · Firm text: Ogilvy Renault LLP · Firm quote: Solicitors for RSM Richter Inc., in its capacity as Monitor for the Applicants · Context quote: Solicitors for RSM Richter Inc., in its capacity as Monitor for the Applicants	PDF

2 Dec 2008	Third Report of the Chief Restructuring Advisor dated December 2, 2008 Fee schedule Engagements: Form: invoice_listing · Rows: Fees: 32257.5 · Rate: 275 · Hours: 117.3 · Quote: Manager \| 117.3 hrs. @$275. \| 32,257.50 · Title: Manager · Row kind: level · Rate kind: standard · Name as stated: Manager; Fees: 342 · Rate: 180 · Hours: 1.9 · Quote: Snr Associates \| 1.9 hrs. @ $180. \| 342.00 · Title: Snr Associates · Row kind: level · Rate kind: standard · Name as stated: Snr Associates; Fees: 108 · Rate: 90 · Hours: 1.2 · Quote: Technicians \| 1.2 hrs. @ $90. \| 108.00 · Title: Technicians · Row kind: level · Rate kind: standard · Name as stated: Technicians; Fees: 69335 · Hours: 234.3 · Quote: Total \| 234.3 hrs. \| $69,335.00 · Row kind: subtotal · Rate kind: standard · Name as stated: Total · Money: Tax: $3.47K · Label: GST · Quote: 3,466.75 · Fees: $69.3K · Quote: 69,335.00 · Total: $76.9K · Quote: 76,873.13 · includes tax · includes disbursements · Approximate: false · Disbursements: $3.9K · Quote: 3,897.18 · Period: End: 2008-11-30 · Kind: cumulative · Quote: TIME SHEET (for the period August 4, 2008 to November 30, 2008) · Start: 2008-08-04 · Approval: Quote: affidavit is sworn in support of the motion for approval of the CRA's fees and disbursements · State: sought · Averages: · Currency: · Invoices: Tax: 1750.83 · Fees: 35016.5 · Quote: Aug 4 to Aug 15, 2008 \| 30788 \| 35,016.50 \| 1,750.83 \| 2,821.83 \| 141.09 \| 39,730.25 · Total: 39730.25 · Period end: 2008-08-15 · Period start: 2008-08-04 · Disbursements: 2821.83; Tax: 303.9 · Fees: 6078 · Quote: Aug 16 to Aug 22, 2008 \| 20779 \| 6,078.00 \| 303.90 \| \| \| 6,381.90 · Total: 6381.9 · Period end: 2008-08-22 · Period start: 2008-08-16; Tax: 243.35 · Fees: 4867 · Quote: Aug 23 to Aug 29, 2008 \| 30780 \| 4,867.00 \| 243.35 \| 447.94 \| 2.40 \| 5,560.69 · Total: 5560.69 · Period end: 2008-08-29 · Period start: 2008-08-23 · Disbursements: 447.94; Tax: 160.83 · Fees: 3216.5 · Quote: Aug 30 to Sep 12, 2008 \| 30781 \| 3,216.50 \| 160.83 \| 446.38 \| 22.32 \| 3,846.02 · Total: 3846.02 · Period end: 2008-09-12 · Period start: 2008-08-30 · Disbursements: 446.38; Tax: 264.88 · Fees: 5297.5 · Quote: Sep 13 to Oct 9, 2008 \| 30784 \| 5,297.50 \| 264.88 \| 28.45 \| 1.33 \| 5,592.16 · Total: 5592.16 · Period end: 2008-10-09 · Period start: 2008-09-13 · Disbursements: 28.45; Tax: 742.98 · Fees: 14859.5 · Quote: Oct 10 to Nov 28, 2008 \| 30789 \| 14,859.50 \| 742.98 \| 152.58 \| 7.06 \| 15,762.12 · Total: 15762.12 · Period end: 2008-11-28 · Period start: 2008-10-10 · Disbursements: 152.58 · Firm text: Doyle Salewski Inc. · Firm quote: Doyle Salewski Inc., of the City of Ottawa, in the Province of Ontario · Hours total: Quote: 234.3 hrs. · Value: 234.3 · Context quote: DSI was subsequently appointed as Chief Restructuring Advisor (the "CRA"); Form: prose · Rows: · Money: Total: $75.2K · Quote: in the amount of $75,204.15, inclusive of Goods and Services Tax · includes tax · includes disbursements · Approximate: false · Period: Kind: unstated · Approval: Quote: an order authorizing and approving the fees and disbursements of the CRA's solicitors, Bennett Jones LLP · State: sought · Averages: · Currency: · Invoices: · Firm text: Bennett Jones LLP · Firm quote: Bennett Jones LLP · Context quote: an order authorizing and approving the fees and disbursements of the CRA's solicitors, Bennett Jones LLP in the amount of $75,204.15, inclusive of Goods and Services Tax.	PDF

29 Oct 2008	Endorsement dated October 29, 2008	PDF

29 Oct 2008	Motion Record returnable October 29, 2008	PDF

29 Oct 2008	Order (re: JCI) dated October 29, 2008 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

29 Oct 2008	Order (re: Lear Corporation) dated October 29, 2008 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

29 Oct 2008	Order dated October 29, 2008 Counsel Ducharme Fox LLP Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

24 Oct 2008	Second Supplement to the Third Report of the Monitor dated October 24, 2008	PDF

17 Oct 2008	Endorsement dated October 17, 2008	PDF

17 Oct 2008	Motion Record returnable October 17, 2008	PDF

17 Oct 2008	Stay Extension Order dated October 17, 2008 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

17 Oct 2008	Vesting Order (re: Ford Motor Company) dated October 17, 2008 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

17 Oct 2008	Vesting Order (re: General Motors Company) dated October 17, 2008	PDF

17 Oct 2008	Vesting Order (re: Lear Corporation) dated October 17, 2008 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

17 Oct 2008	Vesting Order (re: Magna Seating of America) dated October 17, 2008 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

17 Oct 2008	Vesting Order (re: Magna Structural) dated October 17, 2008 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

16 Oct 2008	Affidavit of Lionel Peltier sworn October 16, 2008	PDF

16 Oct 2008	Supplement to the Third Report of the Monitor dated October 16, 2008	PDF

10 Oct 2008	Third Report of the Monitor dated October 10, 2008	PDF

8 Oct 2008	Motion Record (including Second Report of the Monitor) returnable October 8, 2008	PDF

8 Oct 2008	Order dated October 8, 2008 Presiding officer Justice Morawetz	PDF

6 Oct 2008	Supplement to the Second Report of the Monitor dated October 6, 2008	PDF

2 Oct 2008	Direction for Adjournment dated October 2, 2008	PDF

2 Sep 2008	Amended and Restated Initial Order dated September 2, 2008	PDF

2 Sep 2008	Motion Record returnable September 2, 2008	PDF

2 Sep 2008	Order dated September 2, 2008 Presiding officer Justice Mesbur	PDF

27 Aug 2008	Affidavit of Lionel Peltier sworn August 27, 2008	PDF

27 Aug 2008	First Report of the Chief Restructuring Advisor dated August 27, 2008 Fee schedule Engagements: Form: time_summary · Rows: B. Doyle · Money: Fees: $21.8K · Quote: 21,786.50 · Approximate: false · Period: End: 2008-08-03 · Kind: invoice · Quote: Costs for the period June 24, 2008 to August 3, 2008 · Start: 2008-06-24 · Approval: State: unstated · Averages: · Currency: · Invoices: · Firm text: Doyle Salewski Inc. · Firm quote: normal hourly rates charged by Doyle Salewski Inc. · Context quote: The hourly billing rates outlined below are normal hourly rates charged by Doyle Salewski Inc. for services rendered in relation to similar proceedings.	PDF

26 Aug 2008	First Report of the Monitor dated August 26, 2008	PDF

12 Aug 2008	Amended Initial Order dated August 12, 2008 Presiding officer Justice Newbould	PDF

12 Aug 2008	Motion Record returnable August 12, 2008	PDF

6 Aug 2008	Affidavit of Lionel Peltier sworn August 6, 2008	PDF

6 Aug 2008	First Report of the Proposal Trustee and Proposed Chief Restructuring Advisor (re: Doyle Salewski Inc.) dated August 6, 2008	PDF

6 Aug 2008	Initial Order dated August 6, 2008 Presiding officer Justice Hoy	PDF

6 Aug 2008	Notice of Application dated August 6, 2008 Counsel Bennett Jones LLP	PDF

Filing titles, dates, and extracted key facts are public.

CiteProceedings., “Windsor Machine & Stamping Limited, et al” (CCAA). Retrieved 20 September 2026, https://proceedings.ca/case/windsor-machine-stamping-limited-et-al