What the professionals charged
3,597 bills from 234 firms on 874 matters · 9,084 stated hourly rates · as the filings state them
The rate ladder, drawn to scaleThe ladder
CAD · standard rates · drawn at 12 or moreOfficers of the court
Each bar runs from the 25th to the 75th percentile of the stated standard hourly rates in the band, with the median marked — the bar and its three figures are for subscribers. One observation per person per rate, Canadian dollars, undiscounted, on matters with no recognition proceeding.A band with fewer than 12 observations draws nothing.
| Person | Firm | Case | Period | Rate ▼ | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Charles A. Patriziacalled 1976 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Orestes Pasparakiscalled 1995 | Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLPMonitor's counsel | Nelson Education Holdings Ltd.ON · closed | 29 May – 26 Jul 2015 | ••• | Motion Record (Approval of Fees and Activities, returnable… |
| Tony Reyescalled 1988 | Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLPMonitor's counsel | Nelson Education Holdings Ltd.ON · closed | 29 May – 26 Jul 2015 | ••• | Motion Record (Approval of Fees and Activities, returnable… |
| Robert E. Wintercalled 1997 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Jay A. Swartz | Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg LLPCounsel, client not stated | Unique Broadband Systems, Inc. and UBS Wireless Inc.ON · closed | — | ••• | Twenty Fourth Report of the Monitor (Part 2 of 2) dated… |
| Michael BaxterPartner | Covington & Burling LLPTrustee's counsel | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 1 May 2014 – 31 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application for Compensation and… |
| Warren CaywoodPartner | Covington & Burling LLPTrustee's counsel | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 1 May 2014 – 31 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application for Compensation and… |
| Robert E. Wintercalled 1997 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Michael BaxterPartner | Covington & Burling LLPTrustee's counsel | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 1 May 2014 – 31 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application for Compensation and… |
| Warren CaywoodPartner | Covington & Burling LLPTrustee's counsel | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 1 May 2014 – 31 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application for Compensation and… |
| Karen Galperncalled 1993 | Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLPMonitor's counsel | Nelson Education Holdings Ltd.ON · closed | 29 May – 26 Jul 2015 | ••• | Motion Record (Approval of Fees and Activities, returnable… |
| Gale RubensteinPartner · Insolvency | Goodmans LLPDebtor's counsel | Reliance Insurance Company, Canada BranchON · closed | 1 Apr 2014 – 31 Dec 2015 | ••• | Liquidator's Report - 2016.04.12 |
| Franziska Ruf | Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg LLPCounsel, client not stated | Unique Broadband Systems, Inc. and UBS Wireless Inc.ON · closed | — | ••• | Twenty Fourth Report of the Monitor (Part 2 of 2) dated… |
| Kyle J. Ortizcalled 2010 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Graham SmithPartner · Litigation | Goodmans LLPDebtor's counsel | Reliance Insurance Company, Canada BranchON · closed | 1 Apr 2014 – 31 Dec 2015 | ••• | Liquidator's Report - 2016.04.12 |
| Francy KussnerPartner · Litigation | Goodmans LLPDebtor's counsel | Reliance Insurance Company, Canada BranchON · closed | 1 Apr 2014 – 31 Dec 2015 | ••• | Liquidator's Report - 2016.04.12 |
| D. R. Englishcalled 1980 | Aird & Berlis LLPReceiver's counsel | Pembroke Residence Ltd. o/a Knights Inn-TorontoON · closed | 1 Feb – 28 Apr 2015 | ••• | Motion Record returnable May 12, 2015 |
| Peter Hong | Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg LLPCounsel, client not stated | Unique Broadband Systems, Inc. and UBS Wireless Inc.ON · closed | — | ••• | Twenty Fourth Report of the Monitor (Part 2 of 2) dated… |
| David Mann | Dentons Canada LLPCounsel, client not stated | Strata Energy Services Inc.AB · closed | to 31 Dec 2015 | ••• | Application - Returnable July 11, 2016 - Part 7 |
| Grant B. Moffatcalled 1991 | Thornton Grout Finnigan LLPReceiver's counsel | National Telecommunications Inc.ON · closed | 1 Jun – 30 Nov 2015 | ••• | Motion Record of the Receiver dated December 18, 2015 (Part… |
| Grant B. Moffatcalled 1991 | Thornton Grout Finnigan LLPReceiver's counsel | National Telecommunications Inc.ON · closed | 23 Apr – 31 May 2015 | ••• | First Report to Court - Exhibit F to I |
| Christopher J. Fongcalled 2008 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Kyle J. Ortizcalled 2010 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Katherine A. Traxlercalled 1990 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 1 Nov – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Katherine A. Traxlercalled 1990 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Mindy Gilbert | Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg LLPCounsel, client not stated | Unique Broadband Systems, Inc. and UBS Wireless Inc.ON · closed | — | ••• | Twenty Fourth Report of the Monitor (Part 2 of 2) dated… |
| Natasha MacParland | Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg LLPCounsel, client not stated | Unique Broadband Systems, Inc. and UBS Wireless Inc.ON · closed | — | ••• | Twenty Fourth Report of the Monitor (Part 2 of 2) dated… |
| Katherine A. Traxlercalled 1990 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Christopher J. Fongcalled 2008 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Michael De Lellis | Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLPCounsel, client not stated | Cline Mining Corporation/New Elk Coal Company LLC/North Central Energy CompanyON · closed | — | ••• | Sixth Report of the Monitor |
| Christopher J. Fongcalled 2008 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Christopher J. Fongcalled 2008 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Michelle E. Clinecalled 2011 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Randy Hookecalled 1989 | Aird & Berlis LLPReceiver's counsel | Pembroke Residence Ltd. o/a Knights Inn-TorontoON · closed | 1 Feb – 28 Apr 2015 | ••• | Motion Record returnable May 12, 2015 |
| Oscar T. Saunderscalled 2011 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Fay Sulley | Torkin Manes LLPDebtor's counsel | Martin Ross Group Inc.ON · closed | 1 Jun – 21 Oct 2015 | ••• | Ninth Report of the Monitor dated October 21, 2015 |
| Michelle E. Clinecalled 2011 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Cathy CostaAssociate · Research | Goodmans LLPDebtor's counsel | Reliance Insurance Company, Canada BranchON · closed | 1 Apr 2014 – 31 Dec 2015 | ••• | Liquidator's Report - 2016.04.12 |
| Michelle E. Clinecalled 2011 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Luc A. Despinscalled 1986 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| William SkellyPartner | Borden Ladner Gervais LLPReceiver's counsel | Oak Bay Beach HotelBC | 1 Dec – 31 Dec 2015 | ••• | Fourth Report of the Receiver |
| William SkellyPartner | Borden Ladner Gervais LLPReceiver's counsel | Oak Bay Beach HotelBC | 2 Nov – 30 Nov 2015 | ••• | Fourth Report of the Receiver |
| William SkellyPartner | Borden Ladner Gervais LLPReceiver's counsel | Oak Bay Beach HotelBC | 1 Oct – 31 Oct 2015 | ••• | Fourth Report of the Receiver |
| William SkellyPartner | Borden Ladner Gervais LLPReceiver's counsel | Oak Bay Beach HotelBC | 1 Sep – 30 Sep 2015 | ••• | Fourth Report of the Receiver |
| Luc A. Despinscalled 1986 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| Kyla E.M. Maharcalled 2001 | Thornton Grout Finnigan LLPReceiver's counsel | National Telecommunications Inc.ON · closed | 1 Jun – 30 Nov 2015 | ••• | Motion Record of the Receiver dated December 18, 2015 (Part… |
| Magnus VerbruggePartner | Borden Ladner Gervais LLPReceiver's counsel | Oak Bay Beach HotelBC | 1 Dec – 31 Dec 2015 | ••• | Fourth Report of the Receiver |
| Luc A. Despinscalled 1986 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
| C.A. McNeillcalled 1996 | Aird & Berlis LLPReceiver's counsel | Pembroke Residence Ltd. o/a Knights Inn-TorontoON · closed | 1 Feb – 28 Apr 2015 | ••• | Motion Record returnable May 12, 2015 |
| Ji Eun Kimcalled 2015 | Paul Hastings LLPCounsel, client not stated | Montreal Maine & Atlantic Canada Co.QC | 10 Dec 2013 – 22 Dec 2015 | ••• | Second Interim and Final Application of Paul Hastings LLP,… |
What a bill looks likeBenchmarks
Measured across the recordThe blended rate, stated
median of the average hourly rates filings state outright, counsel, over 945 bills. A further 74 bills state fees and hours and no rate; that quotient is kept as its own series and never mixed in.
Counsel by year of call
median standard rate by years since call — 0-4 years (224), 5-9 years (151), 10-19 years (212), 20+ years (264)
Where the rates are
3,597 bills
monitor 591 · receiver 1,013 · interim receiver 38 · trustee 64 · …
Who bills these estatesWho bills
Named in the filings- KSV Restructuring Inc.354
- Deloitte Restructuring Inc.191
- MNP Ltd.182
- FTI Consulting Canada Inc.181
- Ernst & Young Inc.136
- Cassels Brock & Blackwell LLP129
- BDO Canada Limited122
- Aird & Berlis LLP103
- Alvarez & Marsal Canada Inc.91
- PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc.74
- Grant Thornton Limited67
- Dentons Canada LLP62
Bills, counted one per firm per period however many filings restate it. 234 firms appear in the record; these are the 12 with the most.
How to read thisMethod
The frame. Every figure here comes from a fee affidavit, a passing of accounts, a motion record or an officer's report that a court file holds — fees that were filed for approval, which skews to the larger, longer and more contested mandates. It is not a survey of all insolvency work.
The series. The ladder and the tiles use standard hourly rates of named people, in Canadian dollars, on bills with no courtesy discount and on matters with no recognition proceeding. Discounted bills, stated averages and the rare bill that states fees and hours but no rate are kept as separate series and never mixed in. Nothing is drawn from fewer than 12 observations.
What it is not. A court does not test a bill by hours × rate; it asks what value was delivered (Bank of Nova Scotia v. Diemer, 2014 ONCA 851). This page shows what comparable mandates charged, never what a bill should have been. The record holds sixteen Québec fee documents and no French rate tables; it is not a benchmark for Québec.
Every fact carries its document. Each bill and each rate links to the filing that states it; each benchmark cell can be traced to the rates it was computed from through the rates view.